Help!
I started a Roth IRA and contributed $2000 per year for 1998 and 1999. I am doing my 1999 tax return and I discover our married AGI falls in the 150-160k range. Turbotax tells me that I overpaid by $520. I have made a few trades and my holdings have appreciated, making it difficult to track where this $520 went. Assuming I can estimate its current value, can I withdraw it from my account without penalty in order to keep my Roth tax-free?

Thanks for any guidance.
Rob

You have two choices. One is to withdraw the excess contribution AND the applicable income. If you do that you will pay tax and 10% early withdrawal tax on the applicable income.

Second choice is to recharacterize the excess contribution AND the applicable income into a traditional IRA. This eliminates any immediate tax consequence.

In either case you have to compute the applicable income, which is done by a formula described in the regs. You may have to pay a knowledgeable pro to compute it for you.



------------------
Barry Picker, CPA/PFS, CFP
New York, NY