Unanswerable question for me. Totally dependent upon facts and circumstances. If the gain or loss is small, then I'd just pay them out. If gain or loss is large, then you have to consider the issues already discussed. "Small" and "large" gains are in the eye of the beholder, so I can't give you any hard number. You give it your best shot, and present the alternatives to the Plan Administrator, who will then decide. Or more likely, ask which alternative you recommend...