Subscribe (Free) to
Daily or Weekly Newsletters
Post a Job

Featured Jobs

DB/DC Administrator

Primark Benefits
(Remote / San Mateo CA)

Primark Benefits logo

Manager, Client Relationship Management

Guideline, Inc.
(Remote / Solana Beach CA)

Guideline, Inc. logo

Retirement Operations Specialist

Fringe Benefit Group
(Remote)

Fringe Benefit Group logo

Customer Success Associate

Guideline, Inc.
(Remote / Austin TX / Solana Beach CA / Portland ME / San Mateo CA / CO / FL / GA)

Guideline, Inc. logo

Legal Assistant / Paralegal / Plan Document Specialist

Witman Stadtmauer, P.A.
(Remote / Florham Park NJ)

Retirement Plan Administrator

Fulton Bank / Fulton Financial Advisors
(Remote)

Fulton Bank / Fulton Financial Advisors logo

Retirement Plan Administrator

ForUsAll
(Remote)

ForUsAll logo

Client Service Specialist

EPIC RPS
(IL / IN / MA / MD / ME / NC / NH / NY / PA / TN / VA / VT)

EPIC RPS logo

Account Manager

Pentegra
(Remote / West Harrison NY)

Pentegra logo

Product Support Specialist - Conversions

ftwilliam.com part of Wolters Kluwer Legal & Regulatory
(Remote)

ftwilliam.com part of Wolters Kluwer Legal & Regulatory logo

Retirement Plan Administrator

Retirement Solutions Specialists, LLC
(Remote)

Retirement Solutions Specialists, LLC logo

Retirement Plan Administrator

Great Lakes Pension Associates, Inc.
(Remote)

Great Lakes Pension Associates, Inc. logo

Trust Accounting/5500 Specialist

Sentinel Benefits & Financial Group
(Remote / Wakefield MA)

Sentinel Benefits & Financial Group logo

Mathematician or Benefit Analyst (Part-time)

American Pension, LLC
(Berkeley Heights NJ)

American Pension, LLC logo

Client Service Manager

July Business Services
(Remote)

July Business Services logo

Senior Plan Administrator

Fiduciary Consulting Group
(Remote / Murfreesboro TN)

Fiduciary Consulting Group logo

DB Plan Administrator

Aimpoint Pension
(Remote)

Aimpoint Pension logo

Plan Administrator

Aimpoint Pension
(Remote)

Aimpoint Pension logo

View More Employee Benefits Jobs

Free Newsletters

“BenefitsLink continues to be the most valuable resource we have at the firm.”

-- An attorney subscriber

Mobile App image LinkedIn icon
Twitter icon
Facebook icon

BenefitsLink > Q&A Columns >

Who's the Employer?

Answers are provided by S. Derrin Watson, JD, APM

Excluding ESOP Stock

(Posted March 18, 2002)

Question 143: If five or fewer individuals collectively own more than 50% of a corporation (exclusive of stock held in an ESOP) then is the ESOP stock excluded from the calculation to determine a controlled group? Without the ESOP four people own 80% in my situation, but when I attribute the ESOP stock and include the ESOP in the test, they only own 75%. Which way is right?

Answer: Either way can be right, depending on whether it will create a controlled group.

If five or fewer individuals, estates or trusts own at least 50% of a corporation, IRC 1563(c)(2)(B)(i) says that for purposes of determining whether a controlled group exists, stock held by a qualified plan will be excluded, but only if that serves to create a controlled group. Thus, this rule can only be used as a "sword," and not as a shield.

Let's take a couple of examples. Suppose ownership of two companies is as follows:

OwnerCo. XCo. Y
Anne70%100%
Co. X ESOP Trust15%0%
Peter15%0%

Assume that Anne's account balance is 50% of the total in the ESOP. Accordingly, once we attribute ownership of ESOP stock to Anne, she has a total of 77.5% of Co. X, which is not quite enough for a controlled group. So, we go to the next step and try excluding the ESOP stock. Now Anne owns 70/85ths of the company, more than 82%. With the exclusion, a controlled group exists and so we exclude the stock.

Now, let's try a different example. Suppose we are interested in companies A and B, with the following ownership:

OwnerCo. ACo. B
Oscar60%60%
Co. A 401(k) Trust20%20%
Peter20%0%
Quincy0%20%

2,000 employees participate in the Company A 401(k) Plan and Trust, and no one participant owns more than 1% of its assets.

On these facts, without the exclusion, Company A and B are in a controlled group, because Oscar and the Trust collectively have 80% effective control and 80% controlling interest. So, we stop there. (If we were to go on and apply the exclusion, improperly, we would find that Oscar, all on his own, would have 75% of the remaining, nonexcluded stock and there would be no controlled group.)

Let's apply these principles to your question. The four shareholders in question own more than half of each company, and so exclusion is proper if it creates a controlled group. You say a controlled group exists if you ignore the ESOP stock, and otherwise it doesn't. So exclude the ESOP stock.

Let me make a few other side comments here:

  1. You are right that the stock ownership is attributed from the ESOP to its beneficiaries. IRC 1563 has a rule for general tax purposes that there is no attribution from a retirement trust to its beneficiaries, but that rule does not apply to determinations under IRC 414 (the retirement plan controlled group rules).


  2. Remember, as shown in the second example above, that a retirement trust is a trust. Hence, when you are asking if 5 or fewer individuals, estates, or trusts have effective control, you can either look at the trust as a single shareholder, or you can attribute its ownership to its beneficiaries (or attribute it to some and not others if that makes a difference).
  3. The exclusion rules are some of the most complex and troublesome rules in the controlled group arena. That's why I devote Chapter 8 to them in my book, Who's the Employer? The diagrams that appear in the latest version of my book are particularly helpful in sorting through the logic of exclusion situations.


Important notice:

Answers are provided as general guidance on the subjects covered in the question and are not provided as legal advice to the questioner or to readers. Any legal issues should be reviewed by your legal counsel to apply the law to the particular facts of this and similar situations.

The law in this area changes frequently. Answers are believed to be correct as of the posting dates shown. The completeness or accuracy of a particular answer may be affected by changes in the law (statutes, regulations, rulings, court decisions, etc.) that occur after the date on which a particular Q&A is posted.


Copyright 1999-2017 S. Derrin Watson
Related links:

(restricted access)

(restricted access)

© 2022 BenefitsLink.com, Inc.