Who's the Employer?

Answer: I do not believe this is an A-Org style affiliated service group, and you have not given me any facts that would make me think it is a B-Org.

Under the proposed 414(m) regulations, on which taxpayers may rely, the FSO of an A-Org must either be unincorporated or be a professional service corporation (PSC). Both A and B are incorporated and neither is a PSC, so neither can be an FSO. Without an FSO, one cannot have an A-Org relationship.

To have a B-Org, one organization would need to provide services to the other. You have not indicated that this is the case.

In short, based on the facts you have given me, nothing leads me to believe an ASG exists.

But let's turn to your second question. If an ASG exists, all employees of all ASG members are deemed to be employed by a single employer. Can a single employer have multiple plans, each covering different groups of people? Of course they can, so long as the plans can pass coverage. Can a single employer provide different levels of benefits in those plans? If they can pass coverage without aggregating the plans, then yes, they can. An ASG can do just about anything a single employer can do. There is no reason to hamstring the businesses by forcing them to have a single plan or to have identical plans, if the facts will permit something else.

For example, suppose Corp A and Corp B each have 5 HCEs and 40 NHCEs (with no overlapping employees). Corp A wants a safe harbor 401(k). Corp B wants a pedal-to-the-metal defined benefit plan. Will it work? Sure. Each plan will cover half the HCEs and half the NHCEs. Each plan will pass IRC 410(b) without aggregating the other plan. Corp B's plan also will pass IRC 401(a)(26).

I discuss ASGs in chapter 13 of my book, Who's the Employer. Consequences of affiliated status are discussed in Chapter 10, with numerous examples.

• Other Q&A Columns