Subscribe Now!
Free Daily News, Jobs, Webcasts, Discussions
Display and Distribute
Your Job Openings
COVID-19 News
COVID-19 Webcasts

Featured Jobs

Retirement Plan Consultant

DWC - The 401(k) Experts
(Telecommute)

DWC - The 401(k) Experts logo

Defined Contribution Plan Administrator

The MandMarblestone Group, llc
(Telecommute / Philadelphia PA)

The MandMarblestone Group, llc logo

Pension Plan Administrator

DeMars Pension Consulting Services, Inc.
(Overland Park KS)

DeMars Pension Consulting Services, Inc. logo

Retirement Plan Consultant

Cetera Retirement Plan Specialists
(Telecommute)

Cetera Retirement Plan Specialists logo

Plan Administrator

BlueStar Retirement Services, INC.
(Telecommute / Jacksonville FL)

BlueStar Retirement Services, INC. logo

Director of Business Development

ERISA Pros, LLC
(Atlanta GA)

ERISA Pros, LLC logo

401(k) Client Support Specialist

401K Generation
(Altamonte Springs FL)

401K Generation logo

Retirement Plan Consultant

Definiti
(Telecommute / Dallas TX / University Place WA / The Woodlands TX)

Definiti logo

Plan Compliance Analyst

Retirement Planners & Administrators
(Telecommute / Falls Church VA)

Retirement Planners & Administrators logo

Defined Benefits Combo Cash Balance Consultant

Loren D. Stark Company (LDSCO)
(Telecommute)

Loren D. Stark Company (LDSCO) logo

Free Daily News and Jobs

“BenefitsLink continues to be the most valuable resource we have at the firm.”

-- An attorney subscriber

Mobile App image LinkedIn icon
Twitter icon
Facebook icon

BenefitsLink > Q&A Columns >

Who's the Employer?

Answers are provided by S. Derrin Watson, JD, APM

Check All Types of Attribution

(Posted July 5, 2006)

Question 287: Is the following a controlled group: a C Corporation is owned by 2 sisters (the first owns 77% and the second owns 23%). The first sister is a 99% limited partner in a partnership; the corporation is the 1% General Partner. The corporation sells household remodeling items; the partnership installs the items.

Answer: You don't have a controlled group but you do have a group of trades or businesses under common control. Let me explain, with references to the 4th edition of my book, Who's the Employer?. (Subscribers can click to view online the text of these references.)

The entities aren't a controlled group, because they aren't both corporations. The controlled group rules are limited to corporations. (I am assuming that the partnership has not elected to be taxed as a corporation, but as you'll see in a moment, that doesn't change the result.)

Congress realized that the controlled group rules, which apply only to corporations, are insufficient to deal with situtations such as the one here, involving unincorporated businesses. So Congress authorized the Treasury Department to adopt regulations to describe groups of trades or businesses (whether or not incorporated) under common control. [Q 12:2.] Essentially, the same pension consequences attach to controlled groups and to groups of trades or businesses under common control. [Q 12:1.]

For both controlled groups and common control, there must be a controlling interest: the same 5 or fewer individuals, estates, or trusts must own at least 80% of each entity. [Q 12:3.] (Note that for income tax purposes only, the 80% requirement has been repealed. However, thanks to Code 1563(f)(5), the 80% requirement is still in place for employee benefit plan purposes. [Q 8:11.] In running the 80% test, we generally exclude, thanks to the Vogel Fertilizer Supreme Court decision, individuals who neither own, nor are deemed to own, an interest in both businesses. [Q 8:7.]

Additionally, the same 5 or fewer individuals, estates, or trusts must own more 50% effective control. [Q 8:6.] Because the first sister has 77% effective control (the lesser of her ownership in the partnership or the corporation), that requirement is easily satisfied.

The second sister owns 23% of the corporation but has no direct ownership in the partnership. If there were no attribution rules, the sister would be out of the picture. Because the second sister owns 23% of the corporation, it would be impossible for the first sister to own 80% of the corporation.

But attribution rules must be considered. No, there isn't any attribution between the sisters. Neither sister is deemed to own the stock of her sibling. But there is attribution from a corporation to its 5% or more shareholders. [Q 9:14.] Hence the first sister not only owns her 99% limited partnership; she also owns 77% of the 1% general partner interest held by the corporation. More important, the second sister is deemed to own 0.23% of the partnership due to attribution of the corporation's general partnership interest.

Why is the 0.23% interest important? Because Vogel Fertilizer doesn't apply any more. Both sisters own an interest, no matter how small, in both businesses. And so we count the ownership of both sisters in applying the controlling interest test. Between the two of them, they own 100% of the corporation and 100% of the partnership. Result: the two businesses are under common control. So employees of both are deemed to be employed by a single employer.

It is tempting in this case to give the quick answer, "There's no attribution between sisters, so no common control." But the quick answer frequently is not the right answer. You must check every type of attribution.


Important notice:

Answers are provided as general guidance on the subjects covered in the question and are not provided as legal advice to the questioner or to readers. Any legal issues should be reviewed by your legal counsel to apply the law to the particular facts of this and similar situations.

The law in this area changes frequently. Answers are believed to be correct as of the posting dates shown. The completeness or accuracy of a particular answer may be affected by changes in the law (statutes, regulations, rulings, court decisions, etc.) that occur after the date on which a particular Q&A is posted.


Copyright 1999-2017 S. Derrin Watson
Related links:

(restricted access)

(restricted access)

© 2020 BenefitsLink.com, Inc.