- 2 replies
- 2,144 views
- Add Reply
- 4 replies
- 1,053 views
- Add Reply
- 3 replies
- 1,087 views
- Add Reply
- 3 replies
- 1,538 views
- Add Reply
- 4 replies
- 1,530 views
- Add Reply
- 0 replies
- 422 views
- Add Reply
- 8 replies
- 1,565 views
- Add Reply
- 6 replies
- 2,485 views
- Add Reply
- 6 replies
- 4,114 views
- Add Reply
- 5 replies
- 1,319 views
- Add Reply
- 0 replies
- 358 views
- Add Reply
- 3 replies
- 1,755 views
- Add Reply
Participant Support Representative
401k hardship request - Casualty Deduction
I struggle with understanding the Casualty deduction reason for hardship withdrawals. I am not sure if it applies in this case and am asking for any opinions or interpretations.
A bad storm blew through and damaged the roof of a 401k participant's house. Not a federal disaster area and it was his principal residence. The insurance will pay for the repairs but he has a $1000 deductible which he does not have. Can her receive this from the 401k plan under the Casualty deduction reason?
Thank you
Distribution Reviewer
FT William 401k Discretionary Match
I am trying to avoid the 60 day match notice with a discretionary match. I'll be darned but I cannot find anywhere to cap the deferrals taken into account for the match. So for example we have a lot of clients that have no idea how much match they can afford for a given year. So we hardcode the match as a discretionary percentage of the first 4% of pay (could be first 5% of 6%, you get the idea). FT william uses the term "Matched Employee Contributions." I cannot find any where that I can cap that term at a given percentage. Has anyone run into this same issue before?
unit benefit formula
DB plan valuation and plan document with the following non-integrated formula
Unit Benefit for Past and Future service
85% of the participants average annual/monthly compensation multiplied by the participant's years of credited service prior to 12/31/2025 limited to a maximum of 25
Plus: 0% of participants average annual/monthly compensation multiplied by the participant's years of credited service subsequent to 12/31/2025 limited to a maximum of 25
Plan effective 01/01/2025
Owner only, but may add a couple non-hce's in the future.
Question, is this formula doable?
Relationship Manager - DC
Minimizing bookkeeping on a traditional IRA with a non-deductible component
In April 2025, my wife and I filed our federal income taxes for 2024, and she made an $8000 contribution to her traditional IRA (for 2024). Today I reviewed that return; our income had risen, and only $4420 of her $8K could be deducted, so instead TurboTax gave her a $3580 non-deductible contribution to her IRA. I believe it can stay there, and when she goes to withdraw the money, she has a $3580 basis on it, i.e. she will pay income taxes only on the gains. In practice this requires a lot of bookkeeping of regular and non-deductible contributions on form 8606. What a lot of work, potentially for decades, over a smallish error! Is there a way to put an end to the mix of tax types within the IRA , by making a withdrawal or Roth conversion or something?
A related question: IRAs are property of an individual, not a couple, even though we are married-filing-jointly. On form 8606, we are told to add the value of all "your" traditional IRAs. Is that a singular or plural "you"? (My IRAs are surely confusing since I have rolled over some 403b money into them recently.)
414(s) related
Hi
I usually do not exclude anything from the salaries but the following came up as never had to deal with.
Owner just gets normal salary and never a bonus.
All rank&file get salary plus bonus where the total is reflected on gross w-2.
Owner wants to exclude everyone's bonus for pension purposes. Does this fail 414(s)?
Thanks
Training Administrator
Not Sure If Anything Can Be Done Here
Sole Proprietor with a Solo 401(k) plan was with a brokerage firm that was bought by another brokerage firm. Apparently everything was very automatic in transferring investments etc. However, the sole proprietor had an automatic withdrawal of salary deferrals of $2,000 per month. When the new brokerage took over, the automatic $2,000 salary deferrals did not happen. It was always so automatic that the sole proprietor took a deduction for $24,000 for the 2024 year. Later, it was determined that none of the $24,000 went into the sole proprietor's account for 2024.
Does:
1. The sole proprietor just pound sand, suck it up, have his return amended and hand over the income tax, penalties and interest?
2. The sole proprietor have any possibility to deposit $24,000 now and keep the $24,000 deduction for the 2024 year?
Thanks.
Owner only 401k plan with no designation of beneficiary
1 person owner only plan. The 1st RMD was distributed in 2024. The Owner died in September 2025 and did not have a named beneficiary in the plan. He was never married and did not have children, therefore, his death benefit will be payable to his Estate. The Attorney and Financial Advisor want the funds distributed to his "Estate Beneficiary IRA account" as his IRA funds will be transferred here as well. The funds would then be distributed to the beneficiaries of his Estate to an inherited IRA. I have never heard of this.
Wouldn't the funds have to be distributed to his Estate subject to income tax?
1099R distribution code(s) for In-plan Pre-tax to Roth conversion
Background: 403(b)(9) non-electing church plan, participant wants to convert his pre-tax money ($10K) to a designated Roth account within the same plan.
The plan is getting hung up on "conversion" vs "rollover" when there is no distributable event. I only seem to see the term "in-plan Roth rollover (IRR)" these days, and information I see about "Roth conversions" is generally associated with an IRA to Roth IRA. The 1099R instructions state: An IRR is a rollover within a retirement plan to a designated Roth account in the same plan. Yet, there is no plan consensus. 😕
Three scenarios:
A - Participant is under age 59.5, still employed and contributing.
B - Participant is under age 59.5 and severed from employment.
C - Participant is over age 59.5.
It is agreed that box 2a would be 10K, but there is disagreement as to how this transaction is to be reported in box 7 on 1099R and I am hoping someone could offer clarity (TIA).
What is the appropriate code(s) for box 7 and is it the same in all three "in-plan" scenarios?
Employee Benefits Associate Attorney —
Employee Benefits Associate Attorney
Pension Administrator
Benefits Analyst
discovery of a lie during the divorce proceedings
This is for a cash balance plan, so QJ&S applies.
Participant J and spouse S got divorced in 2016. There was no QDRO because as part of the divorce, S waived her rights to J's benefits (kind of...), so nothing was ever provided to the plan sponsor or us as TPA. We never knew or cared about this.
Fast forward to now and we're terminating the CB plan. J calls us because the standard distribution package asks for the spouse to sign if married. J says that he was married, but now he's concerned because in the divorce paperwork, it clearly says that S waives her right to J's benefit in the 401k plan, and that J attests that he is a participant in no other retirement plans. Like many participants, J didn't understand what the CB plan really was.
[It's not relevent, but at the time his balance in the 401k plan was $20K and his lump sum benefit in the CB plan was $3K.]
Now J and the plan sponsor are wondering what to do. Obviously, the best answer is "check with an attorney". I told them without a legal opinion or a QDRO, we can't split J's CB payment.
Any other suggestions? Thanks.
Product Manager, Retirement Services
Designating excess deferrals in multiple plans (402g limit)
An individual worked for 2 unrelated employers in 2025 and deferred into separate 401k plans. They deferred $15,000 into Plan A and $15,000 into Plan B. They are not catch-up eligible and they need a 402g refund of $6,500.
Based on what I am seeing in the regs, the individual ultimately determines which plan holds the excess. If you go by the last-in, first-out method - Plan B would issue the refund. But, Plan B has a very generous match and the individual would have to forfeit some of his match if the refund comes from Plan B.
Can the individual choose Plan A as holding the excess? Or, can they designate a portion of the excess from Plan A and a portion from Plan B? For example, can they request $3,000 to be refunded from Plan A and $3,500 refunded from Plan B?







