"I need clarification on something for the Employer Contribution Credit. The instructions seem to conflict (or perhaps just don't address) with my reading of the actual tax code. I would like to know what others think. Does the 3 year lookback apply for all years? or just the first year? See I.R.C. Section 45E(f)(4) Determination Of Eligible Employer ... and I.R.C. Section 45E(c)(2) Requirement For New Qualified Employer
Plans ...
'Based on 45E(f)(4) and 45E(c)(2) my understanding is that the other than year 1, an eligible employer doesn't have to look at the 3 year look-back. So if an eligible small employer sponsored a SIMPLE or 401(k) or such last year, and it terminated and closed. And next year wanted to start a new plan, they could. The first year of the new plan the employer contribution credit would not be available, but for years 2 -5
(before the phase out wipes it out completely) it would be available.
'The instructions to the Form 8881 don't align with my understanding -- specifically under the Employer Contribution Credit section ... The Form 8881 instructions do not mention that the 3 year lookback only applies
for the first year.
'I know the conservative approach would say to follow the form instructions and the credit would not be allowed. But that's not how I read the actual text of the law. Why bother having 'except that paragraph [2] thereof shall only apply to the taxable year during which the eligible employer plan to which this section applies is established with respect to the eligible employer.' if they wanted
the lookback to apply to all of the years? ... I understand that the lookback period is the 3 years before the plan starts. It's not a rolling 3 years. The three years is fixed. That's not my question. With the SECURE 2.0 rules for converting SIMPLEs to 401(k)s -- we have plenty of employers wondering if they would be eligible for the contribution credit in the later years of the 401(k) plan."