"I have a new client who told me about a program he is running in his company. It is a company that provides clean water to different countries, and employees individuals (non US Citizens) in those companies to run their programs on site -- the company also has a US Staff.
"While discussing his new 401(k) he told me about what he call an Investor Program. In short -- he asks for individuals (Employees and others
as stated above) to invest in the business, and promises them an 8% ROI. He takes their funding and utilizes it for Business Operating Expenses. Investors can withdraw these funds at any time they like -- with the gain attached (although when pressed -- the business owner said he can change that ROI if need be. Nothing is in writing -- and the funds are just tracked in some random spreadsheet.
"He currently has 1.4
Million in Invested Dollars from these Individuals -- but not in liquid cash -- just invested in the Business. He doesn't legally have the right to issue Bonds that I am aware of....and this feels a lot like a Ponzi Scheme. I asked him what he would do if everyone wanted their money at once -- but he had no answer other than to liquidate the business to pay them out.
"I am fairly certain this is illegal --
and my history with this individual would certainly lead me to believe that he thinks himself as not required to obey laws he doesn't agree with....so I wanted to pose this question to the group. Could this structure be something that could be legal? If so, what would he need to do that make it so, or....is his best bet to stop this, get these investors paid out, and hope he never gets caught?"