Jump to content

401kology

Registered
  • Posts

    61
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    1

401kology last won the day on July 28

401kology had the most liked content!

Recent Profile Visitors

The recent visitors block is disabled and is not being shown to other users.

  1. Yes, the 2026 should report a new PT as of 1/1/2026 so the excise tax in 2026 will be greater than in 2025. It is a rolling excise tax on uncorrected PTs
  2. A couple of things to keep in mind here, the prohibited transaction is on the use of the money (i.e., a loan or extension of credit), so the excise tax is on the interest applicable to each plan year and is a rolling tax for subsequent years until the lost earnings were actually deposited to the plan. So a late deferral that occurs in 2022, where the lost earnings were not deposited until 2026 will require reporting on 5 Forms 5330 (2022, 2023, 2024, 2025 and 2026). The excise tax stacks each year. Here is an example: (Calendar‑year employer; 7% rate assumed for illustration only) $50,000 of deferrals were due by 10/15/2025 and deposited 2/13/2026. 2025 Form 5330: $50,000 × 7% × 77/365 = $738.36 amount involved → $110.75 tax. 2026 Form 5330: two rows. Row (i): the 10/15/2025 transaction, $738.36 → $110.75. Row (ii): the 1/1/2026 deemed transaction on $50,738.36 × 7% (the rate in effect 1/1/2026) × 44/365 = $428.15 → $64.22. Line 3 total: $174.97. Correction under § 4975(f)(5) still requires depositing the principal plus lost earnings to the plan. The excise tax is a separate liability. Instructions for Form 5330 (Rev. 12/2025) — IRS Rev. Rul. 2006‑38 — IRS Internal Revenue Bulletin 2006‑29 (Rev. Rul. 2006‑38 text) Below is a snippet of an Excel sheet I created to check the amount of excise taxes owed on the Forms 5330. Lost Earnings Lost Earnings Lost Earnings Lost Earnings Lost Earnings Taxable Period 2020 2021 2022 2023 2023 2020 $725.11 $725.11 $725.11 $725.11 $725.11 2021 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 2022 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 2023 $0.00 $0.00 2023 $0.00 Total lost earnings (includes recurring from prior year)====> $725.11 $833.88 $958.96 $1,102.80 $1,268.22 5330 Calculation $108.77 $125.08 $143.84 $165.42 $190.23
  3. Thanks @Artie M the regulations definitely do not address these types of issues. I have heard the conservative approach is 25% for all affected employees but I agree with you that someone who has been affected since 2024 is not the same as just 2026.
  4. For the record, my thought is that the 25% QNEC would apply to all because the initial failure was in 2024.
  5. Client has been excluding bonuses and commissions since 2024 and we know we can correct by using the 25% QNEC with the notice requirement, but some employees were not impacted until 2026. Do the participants who only had MDOs in 2026 also get the 25% QNEC (similarly situated comes to mind) or can the 0% QNEC apply if they only had MDOs in 2026?
  6. Agreed - thanks
  7. It has been a hot minute since I have been involved with compliance testing, but I am pretty sure I remember that there is a distinct order to the compliance tests. Lets assume we have a 401(k) plan with deferrals, match and after-tax contributions. There are participants who exceeded the 415 limit due to after-tax contributions. It has always been my understanding that the excess annual additions are corrected first and not included in the ADP/ACP Test. The issue here is that the service provided is stating that they do not need to do 415 excess corrections because those get refunded by application of the ACP Test, but in this case we are doing EPCRS corrections with a one-to-one QNEC and including the excess annual additions in that test inflate the QNEC. Just confirming I have no lost my testing marbles and if you have a reference that would be great (was there pre 2009).
  8. Agree with Bill. If the effective date of the plan document is 1/1/2024, that is the effective date that should be reported on the 5500, not the deferral effective date.
  9. For context - The reference to $145k was in the regulations but stated that it would be indexed. When the COLA updates were released for the 2026 calendar year, that is when the $150k was set. So if you look it up and its a publication prior to the IRS' published retirement plan limits (Nov 2025) that could be a reason that the $145k is still reflected.
  10. Thank you @Peter Gulia - That was my understanding, that they did not amend IRC to include safe harbor plans in the new top heavy otherwise excludable rules and was just checking if I missed anything. Appreciate the response!
  11. Am I correct in stating that after the ARA submitted their comment letter to specifically address the top heavy exemption in top heavy safe harbor match plans with dual eligibility that there has not been a technical correction effective post 12/31/2023 and that a safe harbor match plan with dual eligibility will lose the top heavy exemption still? @Peter Gulia?
  12. Thanks @WCC - I agree that if the intent is not to match separately elected catch up, then the document should state that but just the standard "catch up contributions are not matched" provision, my opinion is that you must follow the term in regulations and catch ups are defined as deferrals that exceed either an plan or statutory limit (not verbatim obviously).
  13. The plan document states that catch-up contributions are not matched. In operation, the client uses a separate election for catch up contributions (regardless of the mandatory Roth catch up rules). The match is per pay period and there is no true up. No limit on deferrals. My understanding is that a catch up contribution is not a "catch-up" until it exceeds a plan or statutory limit. The issue is that the plan's payroll provider has not been matching on any contributions that are in the elected catch up bucket. As an extreme example, let's consider 2 participants both over 50: Participant 1 elects only catch up deferrals and has $0 in the regular catch up election. Participant 2 elects only regular deferrals and $0 in the catch up election. Both employees defer a total of $7,500. Part. 1 gets no match and Part. 2 gets the full match. IMHO - I think they both are owed the match because no plan or statutory limit has been exceeded. Wanted to see if anyone else had run into this situation, especially now that separate elections are an option for handling the mandatory Roth catch-ups. p.s. I have also considered that this impacts more than just the match allocation, because the $7,500 in deferrals should be included in the ADP test for participant 1, not to mention the 415 limits. Thoughts?
  14. Thanks! @BG5150 - that was my understanding as well but wanted to confirm as I believe payroll companies are handling it differently.
  15. Re-opening this thread for clarification in practice. The plan document only limits the annual compensation limit to the 401(a)(17) limit - no shut off. And the issue is on the match, not deferrals. The match formula is 100% up to 2% and the determination period is each pay period. The matching contributions stopped at once the employee's compensation reached the 401(a)(17) limit for the year (2025) but the employee had not received $7,000 in match for the year. The plan does not include a true-up provision. Question is whether that was correct in stopping the match or should the match have continued on a per payroll basis until that employee reached $7,000 for the year. Employee made well over the comp limit for 2025. I believe in practice, payroll providers are ceasing the match when the compensation reaches the limit in effect for the year but that does not provide the full match the employee is entitled to even though deferrals continued after the comp limit was reached. Would love to hear others thoughts and see if anyone has a reference since the IRS website assumes annual calculations. I am thinking that since the 401(a)(17) limit is an annual limit that the matching contributions should not have ceased.
×
×
  • Create New...