Our cafeteria plan provides for salary reduction for health premium payments by employees. We have an insurance "subsidy" which, if unused to purchase health coverage, is mostly given to the employee. We do not consider this "subsidy" to be part of the cafeteria plan as not all employees (based on date-of-hire) are eligible for the cash-back feature. We have 2-tier premium rates and nothing other than medical insurance coverage for the employee to purchase with the "subsidy".
Example: Employee is on plan A. Plan A premium is $180 for single, $480 for family. $460 per month in "subsidy" is available to the employee, so employee's monthly cost for coverage is $20, which is taken pre-tax.
If an employee receiving the "subsidy" drops their last dependent, their rate goes down by a significant amount and they would be eligible to receive most of the "subsidy" amount in their paycheck. This is fine during Annual Enrollment or if we are within 30 days of a family status change event.
But it is now September and the employee comes in to drop their spouse and it is determined that the date of the divorce decree was April 6th. We can make the premium change prospective, effective October 1, and drop the spouse retroactive to May 1 (if the plan allows). We will take whatever credit the carrier permits. The employee wants the premium credit back to May 1 ($300 per month).
1) Based on the regs, we cannot retro the election change for the employee, thus the employee's $20 per month salary reduction for June-Sept cannot be refunded.
2) But what about the "subsidy" dollars, which are not considered part of the Cafeteria Plan? Can these be refunded to the employee or are they also forfeitted?
Sorry for the long winded story. Any thoughts or comments greatly appreciated.