- 0 replies
- 773 views
- Add Reply
- 2 replies
- 1,531 views
- Add Reply
- 2 replies
- 1,422 views
- Add Reply
- 5 replies
- 1,770 views
- Add Reply
- When calculating ownership for 401(k) purposes, is ownership specifically voting stock? Their preferred shares don't have voting rights, so that would impact how ownership % is calculated (CS / total CS vs common & preferred / all stock).
-
How should we handle the potential of control groups? While unlikely, if a combination of those holding firms all held interest in another company that added up to 80%, couldn't we run into a control group issue that we'd have no way to know about?
- In this case, I believe the 80% ownership for controlled groups is specifically between 5 or fewer individuals/entities. If the 5 largest stakeholders don't add up to more than 80%, would it be safe to assume we're safe in this regard, as no combination of 5 firms could hit 80% anyways?
- If someone who held stock at this company also was an owner of any of the holding firms, would they then need attributed ownership from that? E.g if John Doe owned 5% of the shares of this company, but also held 50% of ABC Holdings, which held 10% of this company, would John's ownership be 5% (direct) + 50% * 10% = a total of 10% ownership for plan purposes?
- 1 reply
- 1,242 views
- Add Reply
- 4 replies
- 1,685 views
- Add Reply
- 0 replies
- 525 views
- Add Reply
- 1 reply
- 1,073 views
- Add Reply
- 3 replies
- 2,316 views
- Add Reply
- 2 replies
- 1,516 views
- Add Reply
- 6 replies
- 1,736 views
- Add Reply
- Amend to have a retroactive benefit increase
- Amend from QRP allocation to participant allocation
- 7 replies
- 1,822 views
- Add Reply
- 1 reply
- 1,111 views
- Add Reply
- 1 reply
- 1,118 views
- Add Reply
- 0 replies
- 432 views
- Add Reply
- 6 replies
- 1,957 views
- Add Reply
Spin off plan with EACA mandate and changing date of first increase
Looking for guidance. We have a spin off plan effective 4/1/26 with the EACA mandate. The prior RK drafted the EACA to use the first day of the following Plan Year as the date of the first increase. New RK can only use the initial period - 2nd plan year. My question is how to administer for the employees auto enrolled in 2026. Can the new intial period be applied for any of the 2026 auto enrolled participants? 4/1, or could it be retro to employees hired on or after 1/1/26 as long as they get an upddated advanced notice letting them know the first increase will not occur until 1/1/28? I know the conservative approach is to apply the change 1/1/27 in the plan document. Thanks for your help!
Discretionary Match
Plan provides for a discretionary match ( no safe harbor). Match funded payroll basis but is based on year end - so a true up may be required
April 1, 2025 employer stopped the match - participants were notified the match would cease as of 4/1/2025.
1. TPA never amended the document to remove the plan year calculation so....
(i) the match for Jan 1 to March 31st would need to be calculated based on annual compensation - correct?
(ii) Auditors doing the 5500 audit and stated the participants who entered after 4/1 need to get the match. According to them this is a discrimination issue - Here is where I am looking for some assistance.
Discretionary means it can stop/change at any time.
Participants who entered after 4/1 do not get a match - this would not be a benefits rights and feature issue - do you agree.
ACP Testing would be for the full year, but those that entered after 4/1 are not included in the ACP Test - do you agree
Thoughts
What Year to Credit Voluntary After Tax Cont?
I have a plan... all employees are HCEs (1 owner... everyone else earns megabucks). It's just a 401(k) plan.... none of the employees get an ER Cont
One of the employees has asked about contributing a VAT contribution. Can this employee still max out 2025 to $70K ($23,500 deferral + $46,500 Voluntary) at this point? Or would any VAT Cont made now be for 2026?
Extracting Text Data to Excel File for Import into ASC
Hello everyone. I'm looking for an automated method to extract financial account activity data from a *.txt file and import it into an Excel file so we can import it into ASC. I'm sure it can be done via AI. I've tried to use Copilot with limited success. Python seems to be a possible solution. Thank you.
Ownership for a company held by many holding firms?
We requested ownership information for a client that onboarded with us this year. Most of our plans are fairly simple with ownership as we specialize in small plans (I don't think we have a single plan that's large enough for a large plan audit), so it's nearly always just some split between a few employees.
This company sent over a cap table, showing columns for common & preferred stock ownership, outstanding and diluted shares, etc for ~60 lines, some of them being employees holding stock, but also a large number of them (40+ or so) being holding firms or other entities that aren't individuals. A few questions.
While the odds of any of this being particularly relevant is fairly low, especially in the small plan world, I'd prefer to have a solid understanding of their plan ownership; any input would be appreciated. Thanks!
5500-EZ Penalty Relief Program--Question
I have a situation with an application for 5500-EZ penalty relief program and I would very greatly appreciate any comments, suggestions, or advice from anyone who can help:
My wife and I both opened separate solo 401(k) accounts for our respective sole proprietorship businesses. Mine in 2011, hers in 2016. We were each the only participants ever in the respective 401(k) plans. We were each the only participants in the respective businesses. There was no overlap and no involvement of one spouse in the other spouse's business or 401(k) plan. We both recently terminated our sole proprietorships, terminated our respective 401(k) plans, and zeroed out the balanced. My wife took a distribution of about $16,000 (she is over 65) and I rolled my 401(k) balance into my individual rollover IRA.
My wife had a total of about $16,000.00 and I had a total of about $760,000.00. We both terminated our respective plans prior to the rollovers and we both have recently filed Final Form 5500-EZs in early 2026 on a short plan year. It was my wife's first-ever ("first and final") 5500-EZ filing because she always had a low balance, but I have been filing them since 2018, since I have been over $250,000 since then.
· Only after the closures did we learn that we may have run afoul of IRS regulations because for several years while we were operating our 401(k) plans, we had minor children under the age of 21. Therefore, we were actually part of a "controlled group" and my wife was obligated to file 5500-EZs for her plan for 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021, and 2022. (I have filed every year as required once over $250,000 from 2018 through to my final short year return zeroing the plan out in 2026.)
· As soon as we realized this, we also learned of the Rev. Proc. 2015-32 Penalty Relief program and put together a package including the $1,500 check to the U.S. treasury; transmittal form 14704; and her delinquent 5500-EZ returns for those years.
· She also included returns for 2023 and 2024 due to an oversight/fatigue as we no longer had minor children under 21 as of 2023, so neither 2023 nor 2024 were actually necessary. But she included "3H" in the plan characteristics section, "controlled group," even though for those years, we were no longer a "controlled group."
· My wife's first and final 5500-EZ short year filing was filed on Efast on February 10, 2026. The penalty relief application was sent by certified mail return receipt requested to the Ogden Utah location on Feb. 13, expected delivery date February 17 2026.
· She has never been contacted by the IRS about any delinquent returns--no CP 403, no CP 406, definitely no CP 283.
· So, after reviewing copies of the submission dozens of times, over the past couple of days, everything looks properly completed, all forms signed, the red ink legend prominently displayed over the form title on each of the EZ-5500 forms.
· But then today I noticed for the first time that the $1500 check was post dated 3/13/2026 rather than 2/13/2026. Again, fatigure, stress, and just a mistake.
·Our questions are:
· 1. What is the implication or possible impact, including any penalties or disqualifications, of including returns for 2023 and 2024 which were not actually required, and incorrectly including the 3H controlled group description code?
· 2. Will the IRS reject her application due to inadvertently post dating the check? She has plenty of funds in her checking account and the check will not bounce IF it is deposited by the IRS. Also, her checking account is with Chase and the internet indicates they don't care what the date is on the check, they will honor it even if post-dated.
· 3. What is the likely timeline on getting a CP 283? Will we at least get the CP 406 and 403 first? About how long will the penalty relief process take?
· 4. If the application is sent back to her for having a post-dated check and she has to re-submit, what are the odds an intervening CP 283 will be generated based on her filing of a first and final return and/or the penalty relief request? I.E. will that trigger an automatic, quick CP 283 before her penalty relief application can be processed and approved, skipping the 403 and 406?
· 5. Is there anything we should do about the post-dated check? Should we try to call the IRS office in Ogden Utah and explain the check is good and should be deposited and that the post-dating was a mistake?
· 6. Anything else she/we should be doing, or just sit tight for now? Any other advice or suggestions any of you have will be greatly appreciated.
Recent Graduate - Benefits Advisor for EBSA
Tax Withholding on a 402(g) Refund
Participant wants taxes withheld on a 2025 excess deferral. The excess will be Code P. Is tax withholding applied to 2025 or 2026 tax return? Any citation would be helpful.
Post-severance compensation that crosses plan years - practical operation
This issue is the bane of my existence. A plan participant terminates on 12/26/2025 and receives a final paycheck on 1/3/2026. The paycheck is for hours worked in 2025. They don't work any hours in 2026. The plan is a safe harbor 3% non-elective plan. Are they an employee in 2026 who is includable and should receive contributions or because they aren't actively employed in 2026, do you treat them as not existing in 2026 for Plan purposes?
The paycheck is $50.
Do you allocate the $1.50 or do you just ignore it? What if the plan doesn't allocate contributions until into the next plan year (2027) and the participant already took their distribution. Do you actually have the Plan Sponsor fund that $1.50?
Do you ask your plan sponsors to provide you any compensation someone in this scenario earned and pick it up in 2025?
I believe the technically correct to the penny answer is they get the $1.50 in 2026, but what are you doing in actual practice? Do you have a threshold for what you pass on providing?
Same scenario, but the plan is an ADP testing plan. Would you pull that person into your testing?
I realize that common sense isn't all that common, but this is an area where it should be applied, IMO. This is just such a pain to administer and am curious what others do.
HCE Allocations in Failed ACP Test
Although an employer makes matching contributions during the plan year pursuant to the plan document's formula, they only contribute half of the prescribed amount to the HCEs because the plan usually fails the ACP test and it's how the employer attempts to prevent refunds of the HCEs' match. The ACP test, though, still usually fails, even with such small allocations to the HCEs. Historically, they have corrected the failed test by making refunds just based on the small HCE matches. However, the new TPA is suggesting that the correction method must be based on the HCEs receiving enough additional matching allocations to satisfy the plan's formula before calculating the appropriate refunds. I know it's always a good idea to follow the provisions of the doc, but because this seems somewhat counterintuitive and perhaps may yield different results, I just wanted to double check that what the TPA is saying is the correct way to handle the failed test. What do you all think?
Roth catchup and a pooled plan
Yuck.
The plan is a pooled 401k (yes, they still exist!) and now the owner needs do to Roth catchup deferrals. I really don't want to commingle the pre-tax and Roth in the same account.
Is there a discrimination issue if only the HCE HPI has a self-directed account?
I have been suggesting that they move to a participant-directed model for years and I was hoping that this would be the thing that clinched the decision... but the owner says that he's retiring in 2-3 years and doesn't want to go through all the changes for a short term, so I'm looking for a different solution. Part of me hopes there isn't one... ![]()
Any other suggestions (other than "you can't always get what you want, even if you are a doctor")?
Paralegal - ERISA/Employee Benefits
Amendment to increase benefit after plan terminated
One lifer DB plan.
Plan frozen/terminated 12/31/2025 with perfect funding with excess, if any, going to qualified replacement plan (QRP).
Client did not tell me about additional contributions made during 2025, simply forgot. Big amount too.
Now have quite an excess but lumpsum still under 415 limit.
Solutions for retroactive amendments?
Any thoughts?
Thanks
Correction of Late Safe Harbor Matching Contributions Required?
I'm looking into whether correction under ECPRS is required in this situation and want to make sure I'm not missing something.
A Safe Harbor plan makes Traditional Safe Harbor Matching Contributions. The AA says the safe harbor matching contributions are based on salary deferrals for the Payroll Period, instead of the Plan Year. The Basic Plan Document says the safe harbor matching contributions must be deposited into the Plan by the last day of the Plan Year quarter following the Plan Year Quarter for which the salary deferrals were made if the employer uses a period other than the Plan Year, which I believe reflects the regs.
In operation, the plan has been depositing the safe harbor matching contributions into the plan at the end of the year - not be the end of the following quarter.
I believe this is an operational failure under ECPRS and must be corrected? The correction method being adjusting participants for lost earnings from the date the safe harbor matching contributions should have been contributed to the actual date they were contributed?
But the plan sponsor and recordkeeper see no issue, say the plan has been operating like this for a long time, and they have no concerns - Am I missing something?? TIA.
3(16) Compliance Manager
Funding Profit Sharing Contributions Throughout the Year
Let's say a company has 1 owner and a few NHCE participants. They fund 3% SHPS during the year. Can the owner also choose to fund additional contributions to himself during the year?
For example, let's say he decides to fund an additional 6% (in addition to SHPS of 3%) in Profit Sharing. Is this allowed? They would pass Gateway, but we don't know if the General Test would be passing based on 9% to owner and 3% to NHCEs.
If this is allowed, can he fund more than 3% SHPS plus 6% Profit Sharing to himself during the year, while only funding 3% SHPS to NHCEs? At that point, they would not be passing Gateway and additional contributions would definitely be required for NHCEs to pass testing.
Thanks!
3(16) Compliance Manager
Payroll Implementations Associate
Top Heavy Testing Question
We have a Plan that was once a dual Plan, but has since Frozen the Cash Balance Plan leaving the Profit Sharing Plan to operate as a stand alone Plan for now. It's a Safe Harbor Match (safe harbor formula).
The Top Heavy Testing is right on the border, but since it is a Safe Harbor Match I believe they are exempt from the testing and are only required to make the Safe Harbor? I just wanted to make that was still the case, since there would be no Cash Balance Contributions and the Key Employees are only going to receive 401(k) and Safe Harbor Matching contributions.
Thanks!







