- 10 replies
- 3,039 views
- Add Reply
- 1 reply
- 1,346 views
- Add Reply
- 1 reply
- 1,385 views
- Add Reply
- 8 replies
- 3,953 views
- Add Reply
- 3 replies
- 2,220 views
- Add Reply
- 2 replies
- 1,813 views
- Add Reply
- 4 replies
- 1,753 views
- Add Reply
- 0 replies
- 1,337 views
- Add Reply
- 1 reply
- 1,414 views
- Add Reply
- 1 reply
- 1,811 views
- Add Reply
- 5 replies
- 2,591 views
- Add Reply
-
Is it common or acceptable for a DB plan sponsor to take over a year to finalize calculations for 7 or fewer employees?
-
Does switching actuarial firms justify months of silence with no updated estimate or election paperwork?
-
At what point does this become a breach of fiduciary duty or an enforceable ERISA violation?
-
What recourse does a participant have when the plan sponsor won't respond, and DOL appears to be passively monitoring?
- 10 replies
- 4,484 views
- Add Reply
- 3 replies
- 2,213 views
- Add Reply
- 1 reply
- 1,527 views
- Add Reply
- 6 replies
- 15,941 views
- Add Reply
- 4 replies
- 1,906 views
- Add Reply
- Can you have a last day requirement to get a contribution?
- Can you have an eligibility period? If so, can it be setup similarly to a 401(k) Plan? Are there specific rules?
- 3 replies
- 3,803 views
- Add Reply
- 5 replies
- 3,317 views
- Add Reply
Excess Contribution
For the 12/31/2024 plan year, the client has several unresolved compliance issues from the 2022 plan year that remain uncorrected as of 2025. Specifically, there is a 402(g) excess deferral of $2,000 for Participant A, who is a non-highly compensated employee (NHCE), and a 415(c) excess annual addition of $6,000 for Participant B. Based on the records available, neither of these excesses has been corrected or reported to date.
In addition, another plan has two uncorrected issues from the 2022 plan year related to plan-imposed limits. First, a deferral was made in excess of the plan’s stated deferral limit (as defined in the plan document), separate from the statutory 402(g) limit. Second, the employer matching contributions were calculated at 3.5% of compensation, whereas the plan document limited the match to 3%. This resulted in an excess matching contribution. As of 2025, neither the excess deferral (under the plan-imposed limit) nor the excess match has been corrected — the excess deferral was not returned to the participant, and the excess match was not distributed or reallocated to the forfeiture account.
1. What is the appropriate method of correction under IRS guidance, specifically for each of the following issues: the uncorrected 402(g) excess, 415(c) excess, plan-imposed deferral limit violation, and the excess employer match?
2. What penalties, if any, apply to the plan sponsor for not correcting these issues within the applicable correction window?
3. What are the tax implications for both the plan sponsor and the affected participants upon correction of each issue, including income inclusion, excise taxes, and any other tax consequences?
4. What IRS forms are required to properly report the corrections (e.g., Form 1099-R for corrective distributions, Form 5330 for excise taxes, or other applicable forms)?
Clarification is also needed on whether these issues may be corrected under the Self-Correction Program (SCP), considering the time elapsed and the types of failures involved, or whether a Voluntary Correction Program (VCP) filing is required — particularly for the plan-imposed limits and uncorrected statutory excess.
Rollover of After-Tax Employee Contributions to Roth IRA
The plan document allows for the distributions of After-Tax Employee Contributions at any time.
In this case, can you rollover the After-Tax Contributions (in a 401(k) plan) directly into a Roth IRA?
I believe you can and the code should be code "G".
Is that correct?
PTIN user fees for 2026
The Federal Register is scheduled tomorrow to publish the IRS notice of PTIN user fees for 2026. It will say the "amount of the user fee as $10 per application or application for renewal, plus an $8.75 fee per application or application for renewal payable directly to a third-party contractor." There are 14 pages of history and legislation disclosing how the IRS arrived at the new number.
The "big" news is a reduction in the PTIN user fee to $10 from $11. (Start planning now on how to use this windfall. 😀)
How would lacking official inflation-adjusted amounts affect your work?
Imagine there is a US government shutdown in October. (In the past 30 years, shutdowns were 1995—26 days, 2013—16 days, 2018—38 days.) Imagine the shutdown lasts through October.
Imagine the Bureau of Labor Statistics report on inflation to September 30, usually released in October, is not released until late November.
Imagine the Internal Revenue Service’s yearly notice of inflation adjustments for retirement plans, usually released in early November, is not released until mid-December.
What steps would you change or delay while waiting for the IRS’s notice?
Would you put estimates in your software? Or wait for the official notice?
If there is a communication to send, would you:
delay it, if it’s not required by 30 days before 2026?
send it, but describe limits or factors without specifying an amount?
send it, with estimates (flagged as estimated) for each inflation-adjusted amount?
How else might a delay of inflation adjustments affect your work?
Postponement of 457(f) benefits: the competing rules of 457(f) and 409A
It is maddening to have competing rules for 457(f) plans to postpone the taxable event. The 2016 proposed regs. require a 90 day notice, a minimum 2 year deferral period, and a benefit enhancement greater than 25%. However, because 457(f) plans are also subject to 409A, when applicable, it seems that a postponement election must also meet the 1 year advance notice/ 5 year minimum postponement requirements of 409A.
If both statues apply, the rule in the 2016 proposd regs is meaningless except for the requirement to add the enhancement. In other words, complying solely with 90 day notice and 2 year postponement results in an automatic 409A violation. This makes no sense, but I have yet to see anyone in this field take the more logical position just to follow the postponement rule in the proposed 457(f) regs and to ignore the 1 year/5 year 409A procedures.
Has anyone taken the aggressive position to ignore 409A procedures and just follow he 457(f) procedures? This would seem to be good faith, because I haven't seen anything from IRS that definitively requires that both postponement procedures be followed.
AFTAP range certification
This is something I have not had any experience with. Trying to read but not too clear on how and when and what can be done.
A very recent takeover plan for 2024, EOY val. Cannot determine the benefits calculated by prior firm and waiting them to explain but not likely by 9/30/2025.
2024 AFTAP was certified at 110% back in September 2024 and prior years have always been over 100%
By looking at the possible benefits and nice return on investments, I think the actual AFTAP will be certified well over 100% (based on some conservative calculations). Client already deposited 2024 contribution, nice sum. Small plan with 3 participants.
Thinking of generating a range AFTAP for 2025 with at least 100% (based on prior history) and have it certified by 9/30/2025 so that the plan can avoid any restrictions.
If the above is doable, when does the actual AFTAP for 2025 needs to be certified or am I wrong that the actual AFTAP has to be certified by 9/30/2025?
Thanks
Reference guides for TPAs on the annual cycle?
I recently ran across this book, "A Year in the Life of a TPA"-- I downloaded it on Kindle (free) and was impressed by how it simplifies a lot of the "annual cycle" we deal with as TPAs. It seems like a short-but-sweet outline of otherwise complex work. I am considering ordering a few copies for our staff. Has anyone purchased this specific guide? What other reference guides do you recommend for a TPA firm to keep on hand?
Funding Required for years with no AFTAP?
Year 6 of a one participant DB had no AFTAP done.
Therefore benefit accruals are frozen as of the end of year 5. That means no benefit increase for year 6 until a subsequent AFTAP is done and is high enough such that prior year's benefit accruals are restored.
My understanding though is that for funding purposes, that is not an issue for year 6.
In other words freeze the benefits because of no AFTAP but go back and assume a benefit accrual for funding purposes. In other words, benefits are frozen but not considered frozen for funding purposes.
Does anyone agree / disagree?
Thanks!
Employee's "right" to select a retirement date
A SERP of a tax exempt org, provided for vested payment at age 65. Like most such SERPs it was structured as a 457(f) short term deferral. The SERP was later amended to allow the CEO/participant the right to select an earlier vested retirement date, provided it was (A) at least 12 months after the election, and (B) was forfeitable if he resigned prior to that new date.
Allowing a participant this much discretion at first concerned me. However, it is not illegal for employers to accelerate short term deferrals. What is wrong with an employer delegating that power to a covered participant? These are just short term deferrals.
If that does not trigger income tax at the date the power was given the participant, what would be the tax date? Would it be 12 months after the power was granted, i.e. the first day after the 12 months, or would it be the actual date the participant elected if later than 12 months?
Hmmm. The person who drafted this amendment was in the HR Department and was insensitive to 457(f) but I wonder if this design actually works. My primary concerns are constructive receipt and/or the fact that IRS could consider vesting to be a charade after the first 12 months when the participant has this much control.
Retirement Account Manager
Pension Specialist
Offering same employee both Cash In Lieu and Spousal Incentive HRA?
Curious on thoughts about offering both an cash in lieu incentive and a spousal incentive HRA.
Employee Deferrals - Reconciliation Shortages as Late Deposits?
When reconciling employee deferral/Roth contributions to deposits on an annual basis there is a shortage (and overage) for some participants - but a net shortage overall. When this doesn't tie out to a specific payroll (or at least doesn't appear to since I don't have payroll and deposit detail by paycheck) and the amounts can be small ($4 or $20, for example) - do you report these amounts on the 5500 as late deposits? Would you need to track down the shorted paycheck for lost earnings calculations?
Terminated DB Plan Participant Still Waiting After 12+ Months – No Communication, No Distribution Timeline
Hello,
I’m a terminated participant in a small employer-sponsored Defined Benefit Pension Plan that was retroactively amended after the plan sponsor realized employees were mistakenly excluded. I’m looking for advice from those familiar with ERISA compliance and DB administration — especially regarding timelines for distribution, participant communication, and what constitutes a “reasonable” delay.
Here’s a timeline of events for context:
🗂️ Timeline of Events
Mar 2012 – Began employment at Company A.
2015 – Company B launched; work shifted there, but payroll remained under Company A.
Jan 2020 – Owner established a Defined Benefit Plan without informing or including employees.
Aug 2024 – Employees notified the plan would be frozen effective August 31.
➡️ Plan sponsor claimed he had received bad advice and was correcting the error.
Sept 2024 – I was involuntarily terminated shortly before turning 55.
➡️ Termination was attributed to cost concerns related to plan corrections.
Oct 2024 – Received an estimated benefit calculation (2020–2023 only).
➡️ Sponsor stated 2024 portion was still pending.
➡️ I turned 55 and became eligible for benefit commencement under ERISA.
Dec 2024 – Mar 2025 – Followed up multiple times. Sponsor provided vague responses, no new documents, and no updated calculation.
Jun 2025 – Sponsor stated original actuary was replaced by a new vendor who is re-reviewing everything.
➡️ Promised to resend plan documents and updated estimate — nothing received.
➡️ I spoke with DOL rep, who said resolution was expected by September 2025.
Sept 2025 – With four days left in the month, still no update. I followed up again.
➡️ Sponsor responded defensively, said the situation is "stressful" and “complicated,” and that he “can’t provide details” until authorized. Also discouraged me from speaking to DOL or other employees — despite his lack of communication.
My Questions:
Thanks in advance for any insights. I'm trying to avoid escalation, but the silence and lack of transparency have gone on far too long.
401k plan: taking a hardship withdrawal after taking a loan
If a participant takes a loan out of their 401k plan account and they take the maximum amount available - 50% of their vested account balance (they are 100% vested). A few months later, they have a hardship and would like to take a hardship withdrawal that would remove most of their balance in the plan. Is this permitted? If so, it would drop their investment balance and the outstanding loan balance would now be well over 50% of their total account balance.
Thank you for any comments.
If deferrals have delayed effective date of 7/1, but ADP Safe Harbor Match has no Delayed Effective Date, what compensation is used to calculate match?
A new 401k plan is adopted in March 2024 with deferrals effective 7/1/2024, but all other provisions, including the SH Match provisions, have no delayed effective date. I am probably overthinking this, but logic tells me that compensation paid in the period before the employee could even make deferrals (1/1/-6/30) would not be counted when calculating the match. Since the match is tied to the employee deferrals, is there any situation where the IRS would include the compensation before the effective date of deferrals in that SHM calculation?
Thank you
Participant Loans 101
Maybe once upon a time I knew the answer to this question but I wanted to ask because it just came up as a question on a call. We use the Corbel PT formatted Adoption Agreement and thre is an option for loans that basically says "all outstanding loans will become due and payable in their entirety upon severance of employment..."
Can someone please explain to me why I have been checking that box on all of my plans for 20 years 😂 It doesn't change when it's taxalbe. I assume it doesn't affect a loan offset? Or maybe that's it.
Coverage testing when there are a bunch of work-visa employees
I don't like dealing with this issue but we are being referred a chicken/egg farm. There are maybe 5 US citizen FT employees and maybe 20 foreigners on a work visa.
The sponsor does not want to cover them. I'm reading that if they have US based wages they are not a non-resident alien. Well they always have wages in the US. They come and go frequently.
The plan will exclude those under the "part-time" rule and I realize the implications if they do go over 1000 hours and the LTPT issue. I will also include exclude by job classification in the document. What is helpful is that there are no owners or other HCEs to be covered by the plan.
Given no HCEs, I think I'm good on the coverage test by including the 5 US citizen FT employees but excluded the 20+ foreign workers.
Agree? I think I'm solid but don't want any surprises!
Thanks
Setting up a SEP Plan
Sorry, SEP is not something we normally work with but someone is asking me so I'm trying to help them out.
They are just setting up a SEP Plan for a group, 5 employees during the year:
Thanks in advance!
Residual Received After Plan Termination
We have a plan that terminated as of 12/31/24, but we just found out that there was a residual that came in during 2025 and then immediately paid out. How do people handle this type of situation? Do we just file the 12/31/24 as the final? Or do we have to do an additional 5500 showing the money in and out in '25 (which is a small amount)?







