- 4 replies
- 1,491 views
- Add Reply
- 5 replies
- 1,800 views
- Add Reply
- 5 replies
- 3,745 views
- Add Reply
- 7 replies
- 2,331 views
- Add Reply
- 12 replies
- 2,380 views
- Add Reply
- 4 replies
- 2,001 views
- Add Reply
- 5 replies
- 1,855 views
- Add Reply
- 3 replies
- 1,644 views
- Add Reply
- 9 replies
- 2,552 views
- Add Reply
- 0 replies
- 779 views
- Add Reply
- 1 reply
- 1,048 views
- Add Reply
- 1 reply
- 1,118 views
- Add Reply
- 10 replies
- 2,008 views
- Add Reply
- 2 replies
- 931 views
- Add Reply
- 2 replies
- 1,860 views
- Add Reply
Compliance Specialist III
Automatic enrollment - protected benefit?
We have a 401k plan that started in 2023 and is large enough that it uses the automatic enrollment procedures. Now this smaller company is considering purchasing a larger business that has their own 401k plan, that was created at least 20 years ago.
If the 2023 plan is merged into the larger plan, does the automatic enrollment feature have to carry over? Is that considered a protected benefit?
Or, if the smaller plan is terminated and the smaller plan's employees become eligible for the larger plan, and that larger plan does not have auto enroll? Is that a problem?
Thank you
What are Form 5500’s fiduciary-responsibility questions?
The forms for an employee-benefit plan’s annual report ask questions designed to check some points about whether the plan’s fiduciaries meet their responsibility.
Imagine a recordkeeper, third-party administrator, auditor, or other service provider now is thinking about a value-add for next year’s 5500 services.
The idea: List all Form 5500, including Schedules, queries that ask something for which a report’s reader could use the response to detect or suspect a possible breach of a fiduciary’s responsibility. (Not a tax-qualification failure, unless it also involves some other breach of an ERISA fiduciary responsibility.)
Isolating those Form 5500 queries in one list would aid a service provider’s review to spot responses that could lead to government or private enforcement.
Let’s crowd-source the list, with each BenefitsLink neighbor noting one query. Don’t repeat a query already noted. Quicker responders might note the obvious queries; later responders are challenged to find more subtle queries. If enough of us add one item, we’ll collect a complete list.
I volunteer to assemble the whole list, in a table format—with Form or Schedule, part, and line numbers; the query; and an explanation.
Benefit Payable when no QDRO was written
I have a somewhat unusual situation. We have a defined benefit plan that was frozen back in 2017. The Plan Sponsor recently amended the Plan to allow for lump sum payments. We had a terminated vested participant who just passed away. The only death benefit was the QPSA for married participants. This individual was divorced (I believe back in 2020).
The Plan sponsor received a copy of the divorce settlement from the ex-wife after the Participant died. The divorce settlement stated that the full benefit from the defined benefit plan was payable to the spouse. No QDRO was ever written.
The Plan Document is an FIS Cycle 3 Document with the following language:
5.22 QUALIFIED DOMESTIC RELATIONS ORDERS
All rights and benefits, including elections, provided to a Participant in this Plan shall be subject to the rights afforded to any Alternate Payee under a "qualified domestic relations order." Furthermore, a distribution to an Alternate Payee shall be permitted if such distribution is authorized by a "qualified domestic relations order," even if the affected Participant has not reached the "earliest retirement age." For the purposes of this Section, "qualified domestic relations order" and "earliest retirement age" shall have the meanings set forth under Code §414(p).
A domestic relations order that otherwise satisfies the requirements for a "qualified domestic relations order" will not fail to be a "qualified domestic relations order": (i) solely because the order is issued after, or revises, another "qualified domestic relations order"; or (ii) solely because of the time at which the order is issued, including issuance after the Annuity Starting Date or after the Participant's death.
We told the ex-wife that she needs a QDRO before any payment can be made. However, there is some disagreement in our office as to whether or not there are any benefits payable to the ex. My arguement is that the Participant died prior to the request for any payments to begin. He had attained Early Retirment Age but was a few years from Normal Retirement Age. As an unmarried Participant, there is no death benefit so the ex is not entitled to any benefit.
Another administrator in the office thinks that if a QDRO is written, then the death of the participant should not affect the payment available to the ex since she was the Alternate Payee and entitled to 100% of the benefit.
I still think any benefit payable to the ex is contingent on the Participant being alive at the time an election is made.
The Plan Sponsor has no problem with paying the benefit to the ex if she can get a QDRO issued.
Any thoughts out there on the benefit payable in this situation?
Senior Associate, Retirement Plan Administration (Audit)
Senior Associate, Retirement Plan Administration (Testing)
Money Purchse Plan Merging into new Profit Sharing Plan
We have a money purchase plan that the client wants to merge into an new profit sharing plan effective 1/1/2026. Since the psp is new, does it need to have the auto enrollment provisions? Or because of it being a merged plan, it won't need those auto enrollment provisions?
Does anyone have any examples of a merger agreement that I can use?
Is there anything else that is needed? The participant notices will be going out.
Missing participant with fake Social Security Number
We are trying to terminate a plan but we have a participant who worked a long time ago for the company and provided a fake social security number. The amount of the benefit is small however do we set up an automatic rollover IRA with the fake social security number or do we forfeit the benefit?
415(c) limitation for terminating DC plan
Suppose a calendar year plan terminates 7/7/2025. A question has arisen as to the proper 415(c) reduced limit. According to treasury regulation 1.415(j)-1(d)(3) (emphasis is mine) fractional parts of a month are included. So the proper fraction is 7/12, not 7.226/12, correct?
(d) Change of limitation year -
(1) In general. Once established, the limitation year may be changed only by amending the plan. Any change in the limitation year must be a change to a 12-month period commencing with any day within the current limitation year. For purposes of this section, the limitations of section 415 are to be applied in the normal manner to the new limitation year.
(2) Application to short limitation period. Where there is a change of limitation year, the limitations of section 415 are to be separately applied to a limitation period which begins with the first day of the current limitation year and which ends on the day before the first day of the first limitation year for which the change is effective. In the case of a defined contribution plan, the dollar limitation with respect to this limitation period is determined by multiplying the applicable dollar limitation for the calendar year in which the limitation period ends by a fraction, the numerator of which is the number of months (including any fractional parts of a month) in the limitation period, and the denominator of which is 12. In the case of a defined benefit plan, no adjustment is made to the section 415(b) limitations to reflect a short limitation period.
(3) Deemed change of limitation year. If a defined contribution plan is terminated effective as of a date other than the last day of the plan's limitation year, the plan is treated for purposes of this section as if the plan was amended to change its limitation year. Thus, the rules of this paragraph (d) apply to the terminating plan's final limitation year.
PBGC Coverage
I recently inherited DB/401k combo plans. The company is an LLC and currently has only included the husband's partnership income for benefit purposes (wife has never participated). For 2025, they want to bring in the wife and daughter. Will this cause the DB plan to require PBGC coverage?
401k Termination with Partners
A partnership (2 partners) with a safe harbor match 401(k) wants to terminate the plan. Plan is top heavy. Historically the partners' K1s are not completed until late September of the following year. Also historically, the partners make deferrals during the plan year which are matched, usually incorrectly and corrections are needed after the K1s are available.
To terminate the plan I was thinking we remove match for HCEs (the 2 partners are the only HCEs) starting 1/1/2026, and terminate the plan in 2026 after the K1s are completed and we know that we have the correct match for 2025. Currently there is enough funds in the forfeiture account to fund the 2026 safe harbor match for the non-HCEs, and there is a very low risk that the partners 2026 K1 compensation would not support their salary deferrals, which I'm sure they would continue to make.
Appreciate any feedback or ideas.
Thank you.
What maximum repayment period do you like for a participant’s principal-residence loan?
A loan a participant uses to buy her principal residence may set a repayment period longer than five years (within what the plan’s governing documents, often including a written policy or procedure, allow).
But if the plan’s sponsor-administrator is listening to your advice, what maximum do you suggest?
50 years?
30 years?
20 years?
15 years?
Something else?
The longest repayment period the recordkeeper agrees to process?
And whichever maximum you suggest, why do you prefer it over other possibilities?
Account Manager (Retirement Plan Administrator)
Roth Catch Up, Spillover/Linked NQDCs and deemed Roth elections
I came across this article from Verrill about implementing Roth Catch Ups when a plan has a provision to spillover deferrals to a NQDC once the 401(k) limits are reached. The article in particular highlights a potential conflict between giving the participant an effective opportunity to elect out of a deemed Roth election and a requirement to make deferral elections before the start of the year for the NQDC.
The article makes suggestions on steps to take now to be sure the operation and administration of plans with the spillover/link to a NQDC is reviewed before 2026 starts, and that everyone involved with the plan - plan administrator, plan sponsor, service providers, participants - are all informed.
This wasn't on my radar screen when discussing implementing Roth Catch Ups, so I am sharing it in case others also have plans that use these features.
410(b) Testing with Control Group
We have a client that maintains 2 plans with us, one of which uses safe harbor match and the other that does not use a safe harbor contribution. They became a control group 2 years ago and we have relied on the transition rule to avoid coverage but that is expiring. What happens if the plans will not pass coverage to be able to be tested alone and technically need to be tested together? I know you are not able to aggregate plans for testing when one is safe harbor and one is not. At this point, they do not want to change the plan design of either plan so we are trying to figure out how to fix this if coverage fails.
Retirement Plan Recordkeeper
mandatory automatic enrollment count... and part-time employees
Talking to a potential plan, and there are two f/t employees and 10 who are 'half-time'. Assuming that these people really do work only half of a f/t schedule, do the rules really let us treat this as 2 + (10 x 50%) = 7 and therefore exempt from the mandatory automatic enrollment? I realize that it might be safer to just include it for many reasons, but if the client is really against it... it's OK, right? Thanks.
Maximum Deductible Contribution - 2-person Plan
I just want to make sure I'm accurate in this. A Plan has two participants, a husband & wife, both of which are deferring th maximum 401(k) contribution for the year:
Husband - $100,000 salary
Wife - $23,000 salary
Wouldn't the maximum deductible contribution be 25% of the total between them ($123,000 x 25%)?
I know the wife's full salary is being deducted as a 401(k) contribution, but couldn't we still use her salary and give the husband the total 25% of their combined salaries as a profit sharing contribution since her salary is still technically eligible income?
Thanks in advance!
Off calendar year 5500
What year do you file the 5500 for if the plan is an off calendar year plan. For some reason I wasn't able to read in the 5500 instructions on which year you'd file the 5500 for. Maybe I'm missing something?
Senior Fog
Client has sold the assets of their LLC, employees received their last paycheck 9/2/2025 and were obviously notified of the plan closing.
The business is not closing, and the new owners do not want the responsibility of the existing plan.
Can the plan termination date be 12/31/25 even though the employees were off payroll earlier?
In order to calculate the employer contribution, obviously a P&L is needed; I have not yet seen a P&L for less than a 12 month period.







