Jump to content

david rigby

Mods
  • Posts

    9,202
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    119

Everything posted by david rigby

  1. Minor clarification. Are you stating that both plans are terminating? The PBGC will take "missing participants" only if the DB plan is terminating. BTW, I'm not sure about the answer to your question, but I doubt that the PBGC would look favorably on it. There is a proposed IRS reg that permits a DC plan to set up an IRA for missing participants under certain circumstances. http://www.benefitslink.com/IRS/revrul2000-36.shtml
  2. As so often is the case, the website can be a great place to start. Go here. Use the Search function with words such as "demutualization" or "prudential".
  3. One minor caution. IRC 411(a)(8) defines the latest point at which the plan can define NRA. 411(a)(9) then defines "normal retirement benefit", commencing at NRA. But many plans also use a definition of NRB. This plan definition should not be confused with the Code definition.
  4. Sounds to me like that provision does incorporate 401(a)(17) by reference. Yes, the plan can be amended to use a $170K limit, but IRC411(d)(6) will require that any resulting benefit not be less than the accrued benefit immediately prior to the change. Has any participant already exceeded $170K? If not, such amendment should accomplish your goal.
  5. I'm skeptical also. Sounds to me like a plan amendment, which means the plan is not frozen. Or perhaps it is frozen, then amended, and frozen again.
  6. Suppose a DB plan with mandatory employee contributions: 1. Is it possible that SSCRA could be interpreted to require the employer to make contributions on behalf of the employee? 2. Is it possible that SSCRA could be interpreted to require a minimum of 6% interest? I think the answer to both is NO, but let's hear other opinions.
  7. "...Alternatively, you could treat the switch to the new employer as having terminated the employees' service with the old employer. That would require full vesting of account balances." Why?
  8. Probably look to the terms of the plan for answers to both questions. w/r/t the union status, it appears that the employment status has not changed. Why would anyone think that union representation changes employment status? The presence of the union may or may not change whether the employees are eligible for future accruals. w/r/t the layoff vs. termination, it's a good question. Ideally, the plan should address it, but we should not be surprised if it does not. Then might look to other personnel practices for help in being consistent. As always,precedence can be mighty useful.
  9. Your alternatives should work. Another method is to limit any HCE's allocation to $X or Y%, without limiting NHCEs. Remember that you are permitted to discrminate against one or more HCE's.
  10. To the best of my knowledge, the provisions of a "divorce decree" are not relevant. The plan cannot divide the benefit between X and Y. The only document that can do that is a Qualified Domestic Relations Order.
  11. Try page 10 of IRS publication 590. http://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/p590.pdf
  12. Huh? I don't see any double attribution. Are the families related to each other?
  13. Entirely dependent on Canadian tax law.
  14. ... a bit more. Schedule B is open to public inspection except when attached to Form 5500-EZ. Schedule E is not open to public inspection. Schedule F is not open to public inspection.
  15. Andy, I think you are on the right track. The occurrence of a distributable event is important. If the person has attained such an event but returned to employment, then you have some flexibility. For example, EE leaves at age 50 as a VT. Reaches age 55 and commences payments under early retirement provisions. Rehired at age 58. The plan could suspend payments, subject to the existence of such provisions in the plan. The plan is not required to have such provisions. The accompanying discussion by KJohnson and Kirk focuses on whether a plan can be amended to add such provisions when not already present.
  16. What do you want to do? If the goal is to permit employees to manage their retirement, then the plan provisions and the personnel administration can, in tandem, help. Suppose the employee has a legitimate severance of employment amnd commencement of benefits under the early retirement definitions. At a later date, the employer rehires the employee (possibly parttime, but not necessarily), and the plan benefit does not change. Ideally, the plan should make it clear that no suspension will occur, the employee can contine to earn credited service, and that benefit at subsequent severance of employment will be redetermined at that time, likely with an adjustment for the value of any benefits received. In the real world, this very often means that the benefit does not change at the later retirement date. This might be a very good process, depending on the type of employer. Example, a hospital. Note, that the original severance of employment should not be on Friday, with a rehire date on Monday. Don't play games with the timing.
  17. In what way does having employees join a union affect whether a plan is top heavy? Are those employees exiting the current plan?
  18. Yes. To elaborate on Frank's alternatives: the method chosen is an accounting method. The plan sponsor chooses it the first time. To change it may require prior IRS approval.
  19. Your title to this question confused me. Are you asking about retirement benefits in pay status? LTD coverage as an active employee/LOA? What type of plans are you referring to? Are they covered under a benefit program of a Canadian company? US company? US subsidiary of a Canadian Company? Canadian subsidiary of a US company? How are these employees paid? Are they Canadian citizens living in the US? Paid in US dollars? Do they work for a US corporation? It seems unlikely that Canadian law could modify the terms of any plan in the US.
  20. I agree, it may not matter. Just curious about whether this owner is applying the same standards to all employees. Also curious whether the owner actually understands what plan he really has. One of the worst scenarios is a top-heavy 401(k) plan (unless there is another plan to absorb the minimum).
  21. Are all employees being treated the same?
  22. That is my understanding as well. Since there is no investment/expense risk being born by plan participants, this issue gets less attention, but I think the same rules would apply. Also of note is the "risk" born by the PBGC, so it should not be considered irrelevant.
  23. It is my understanding that the insurance company cannot require the use of SSN as the ID number. Others may have more information on this subject. Identity theft (which by the way is really all about money) is a very serious problem. You might find some useful info here: http://www.idtheftcenter.org/
  24. My hunch is that the employee will look to the plan sponsor to keep that data, assuming that the after-tax deductions were done properly in the first place. The prior recordkeeper may not be co-operative for a number of reeasons. For example, raising the question may have made them realize they made a mistake, or perhaps the prior TPA knew there was a problem earlier and did not follow-up. It is also possible that the employer did not report it properly to them. There may also be a TPA prior to that one. At any rate, the affected employees are going to be mad at somebody. Probably cannot assume the employees have records; not sure if a W-2 would help, but asking is better than ignoring the problem.
  25. To be precise, the equation of balance mentioned here is really a subset of the correct equation: PVB = PVFNC + sum(outstanding balance of amortization bases) + (Assets - Credit Balance) See IRS Reg. 1.412©(3)-1(B)(1). http://www.access.gpo.gov/nara/cfr/cfrhtml...26cfrv5_00.html (Of course, this reg. pre-dates the existence of the Reconciliation Account.)
×
×
  • Create New...