"The plan document states that catch-up contributions are not matched. In operation, the client uses a separate election for catch up contributions (regardless of the mandatory Roth catch up rules). The match is per pay period and there is no true up. No limit on deferrals.
"My understanding is that a catch up contribution is not a 'catch-up' until it exceeds a plan or statutory limit. The issue is that the
plan's payroll provider has not been matching on any contributions that are in the elected catch up bucket. As an extreme example, let's consider 2 participants both over 50: Participant 1 elects only catch up deferrals and has $0 in the regular catch up election. Participant 2 elects only regular deferrals and $0 in the catch up election. Both employees defer a total of $7,500. Part. 1 gets no match and Part. 2 gets the
full match.
"IMHO -- I think they both are owed the match because no plan or statutory limit has been exceeded. Wanted to see if anyone else had run into this situation, especially now that separate elections are an option for handling the mandatory Roth catch-ups. I have also considered that this impacts more than just the match allocation, because the $7,500 in deferrals should be included in the ADP test for participant
1, not to mention the 415 limits. Thoughts?"