"This Technical Release addresses two issues. First, to the extent proxy advisory firms either: [1] exercise authority or control over shareholder rights attributable to shares that are ERISA plan assets, including the voting of proxies; or [2] provide advice for a fee to ERISA plans about how such plans should exercise proxy voting rights attributable to shares of stock they own, this Technical Release clarifies that such proxy advisory firms must meet ERISA's functional fiduciary requirements.
"Second, and relatedly, where a state law mandates disclosure to investors by proxy advisory firms only when they make recommendations other than for the purpose of maximizing risk-adjusted return for the advisee, such laws are generally not preempted by ERISA. ERISA fiduciary provisions do not alter this result. ERISA's fiduciary duties require that actions be taken with respect to a plan investor only for the purpose of maximizing risk-adjusted financial return. For that reason, no plan governed by ERISA should ever receive a disclosure under such a state disclosure law, and, accordingly, no relationship between that law and any ERISA plan would be created. Consequently, such a state law neither has an impermissible connection with, nor makes a prohibited reference to, ERISA plans, and it generally would not be preempted by ERISA." MORE >>