Could have sworn the first word of the subject was control, not controlled. So, forget the rest of this paragraph. Pet peeve: there is no such thing as a control group, unless you are talking about a scientific experiment. Repeat after me: controlled group, controlled group. Not so hard, huh? But the way things are going for me today somebody is going to find some authoritative publication that uses the offending phrase! Serve me right for picking on the equivalent of grammar on the internet.
Back to the question: no. It would fail all 401a4 and 410b tests.