- 6 replies
- 1,545 views
- Add Reply
- 5 replies
- 1,406 views
- Add Reply
- 3 replies
- 977 views
- Add Reply
- 2 replies
- 3,054 views
- Add Reply
- 2 replies
- 802 views
- Add Reply
- 8 replies
- 1,299 views
- Add Reply
- 9 replies
- 1,914 views
- Add Reply
- 3 replies
- 1,230 views
- Add Reply
- 2 replies
- 1,946 views
- Add Reply
- 6 replies
- 1,464 views
- Add Reply
- 3 replies
- 881 views
- Add Reply
- 3 replies
- 2,830 views
- Add Reply
- 1 reply
- 7,894 views
- Add Reply
- 2 replies
- 879 views
- Add Reply
Lump Sum Payment Offered by Former Employer
Hello,
A former employer offered an ESOP payout in lump sum. They will be diversifying the assets for anyone who does not take the lump sum, and the investment will be into a money market account. To reframe this more concisely, my shares will be purchased back by the company prior to 12/31/2025. I know the company is likely experienced more thanv a 3X increase in share value due to their rapid growth in the past year. The most recent valuation was at 12/31/2024. Will they need to perform an interim valuation, or will my shares be valued at the 12/31/2024 value, which is almost certainly 1/3 or less of the current value of shares? Anything I should do? Wondering if there are attorneys who specialize in this area whom I should consult with, or if this is a lost cause. Thank you!
May we recharacterize deferrals mistakenly processed as Roth back to a participant’s proper non-Roth?
The Treasury’s rule to implement § 414(v)(7)’s requirement that a higher-wage participant’s age-based catch-up deferrals must be Roth contributions includes this:
“Permitted correction on Form W–2. A plan may correct a section 414(v)(7) failure by transferring the catch-up contribution (adjusted for earnings and losses in accordance with § 1.402(g)–1(e)(5)) from the participant’s pre-tax account to the participant’s designated Roth account and reporting the contribution (not adjusted for earnings and losses) as an elective deferral that is a designated Roth contribution on the participant’s Form W–2 for the year in which the elective deferral was originally excluded from the participant’s gross income. However, this correction method may be used only if the participant’s Form W–2 for that year has not been filed or furnished to the participant.” 26 C.F.R. § 1.414 (v)–2(c)(2)(ii) (final and effective, but not yet compiled).
I’m wondering whether a plan’s administration may do the converse: for deferrals that need not have been processed as Roth contributions, transfer that amount (adjusted for investment gain or loss) to the participant’s non-Roth subaccount and wage-report deferral amounts accordingly (if all steps are complete before W-2s run).
The Treasury’s rule doesn’t explicitly say so. Yet, it seems logical and within proper plan accounting. But I hope BenefitsLink neighbors would spot weaknesses in my logic.
Here’s my hypo:
A plan has only elective deferrals, no nonelective or matching contribution. The plan excludes key employees and highly-compensated employees. The plan provides no limit on elective deferrals beyond what’s needed for the plan to tax-qualify.
Suppose a 62-year-old § 414(v)(7)-affected participant has specified non-Roth for all her deferrals (and, despite the employer/administrator’s efforts, has not communicated anything about her preference regarding 2026’s Roth catch-up constraint). Her instruction for deferrals—specified by dollar amount, not a percentage of any measure of compensation—is $1,375 each pay.
Her deferrals for the year’s first 17 (of 26) pays are within the without-catch-up limit. The 18th pay would have most of its deferral allocated to the normal limit, but some to catch-up. And pays 19-26 would be wholly allocated to catch-up.
Imagine the employer, fearing a § 414(v)(7) failure, mistakenly stops this participant’s non-Roth deferrals sooner than is necessary and, applying what the administrator assumes is a deemed election, treats as Roth contributions some of what could properly be non-Roth deferrals. The participant, still inattentive, ignores the employer/administrator’s communications.
On Friday, January 1, 2027, the participant (following her New Year’s Day custom) checks, online, her plan account, and sees the unrequested amounts in Roth subaccounts. On Saturday, she asks her friend, an associate in a law firm’s employee-benefits practice, about this. After hearing him explain the essence of § 414(v)(7), she explains she prefers non-Roth, and wants to tolerate Roth only for a deferral that can’t be made as non-Roth. He suggests, cautiously, that she ask her employer whether it will adjust amounts between the Roth and non-Roth subaccounts. On Monday, the participant calls her employer.
The payroll and human-resources managers both are willing to do adjustments and complete them before W-2s are run, but only if the retirement plan’s third-party administrator says it would be proper.
BenefitsLink neighbors, would you suggest allowing such a Roth to non-Roth transfer?
What issues am I missing?
Misclassification correction
We have discovered that, due to a payroll setup issue, employee deferrals to our SIMPLE IRA plan were calculated on an after-tax basis instead of a pre-tax basis from January to July 2025. Can we fix this by adjusting the remaining payrolls in 2025 to ensure each participant's total annual deferral matches their elected percentage of compensation for the remainder of the year? What would be the appropriate correction method?
Missed FSA Contribution - how to handle
During a review of payroll deductions and benefits records, I discovered that one of our employees had a missed HCFSA deduction earlier this the year (system/timing issue from when the employee started his employment). If no corrective action is taken, the employee will be about $120 short of his elected annual goal.
When I reached out to the employee to make him aware of the situation, he stated he does not want additional money to be taken out of an upcoming paycheck as a correction - he wants to leave things alone.
What are my options? Are we required to take the additional $120 before the end of year to ensure that money deferred equals his annual election? If the employee objects, what regulation/statute/article am I pointing him to so that he understands that this is required?
Related but separate, If someone misses FSA contributions because they are on unpaid medical leave (not FMLA, but state mandated leave) and underfunds an FSA for the annually elected amount, how should that be addressed?
TIA
A Happy Thanksgiving
I hope you all have a great Thanksgiving, unsullied by productive thought. (We are having our meal on Saturday, as many family members can't make it tomorrow, so I'll be working tomorrow - great time to catch up on stuff with no phone/e-mails!)
Enrolled Actuary
safe harbor for those still employed on LDOY only
I doubt this is possible but I wanted to be 100%. We've always provided the 3% nonelective safe harbor to all eligible regardless of employment condition on last day or hours worked.
A large client does not want the terminated employees to get 3% as the cost is fairly high. A 3% profit sharing plan to those still employed does pass coverage but the plan will not pass ADP and the client is firm - no corrective distributions.
Is it possible to test the terminated employees ADP (there are no HCEs in that group) and only give the safe harbor to those still employed? The plan is not top heavy.
Just taking a wild shot on this. Thank you,
Tom
Question About Eligibility Language
I review a lot of plans where eligibility is written as "Full-time employees working 30 hours per week".
To me, this raises multiple concerns:
First, it doesn't account for variable hour employees of ALEs and lookback/measurement/etc.
Second, and more concerning to me, is that the language is loose. If an employee hits 30 hours in one week, is that employee not then eligible? Especially if 'Full-time' is not a defined term?
There has to be a better way of drafting that, right? Or am I just picking nits?
Thanks in advance!
Prior year testing for first plan test
Safe harbor 401k plan has a prior inactive discretionary match. For 2026 they are removing the safe harbor match and reinstating the discretionary match. Can the plan document use prior year testing under the first plan year method in order to assume 3% for NHCE’s for purposes of the ACP test? I was thinking no since there has previously been a discretionary match and adding it back does create a first plan year. But as always I appreciate your feedback!
Failed DCFSA 55% Average Benefit Test
We offered the new maximum DCFSA limit ($7,500), performed the test following our open enrollment period and have one HCE that elected the new maximum $7,500, that needs to be reduced in order to pass the test. My questions are:
1. Since it's possible for us to have another HCE enroll mid-year, am I correct that we have to apply the same reduction to any HCE mid-year enrollees?
2. If yes, how do we determine what the reduced amount should be?
3. Other than exclude HCEs altogether moving forward or setting a low election maximum, is there anything else I'm missing?
ERISApedia Operations Manager
Technical Amendment Due To Mistake At Plan Setup
We are taking over a client whose TPA messed up the original plan setup and didn't put in the correct provisions for certain things (particularly Normal Retirement Age & Vesting Schedule). The question is, how far back can we go to correct these things (the plan is roughly 2 years old, the client just didn't notice the error until now)? Or can we not do them retroactively and just have to do it moving forward.
I'll be honest, this is one I've never encountered so I wanted to be sure we did it correctly.
Director, Customer Experience
Seeking new IT Provider
Hi folks,
Anyone have any recommendation for an IT service provider who excels at Security and can host a virtual TPA practice? Just found out my local service provider is getting out of the business as soon as possible so hoping to make a move by year's end.
Thanks to anyone. If more comfortable, can message me direct.
California "stay or pay" rule and taxation of delayed signing bonuses
The California "stay or pay" rule effective January 1, 2026 will in general prohibit clawbacks when an employee leaves employment. However, under limited circumstances, the rule does not apply to a signing bonus. Among the conditions for it not applying is that the employee must have the option to delay the signing bonus until the end of the retention period.
Has anyone thought about the taxation of the signing bonus if it is deferred? Presumably, if it is considered "made available," it would be taxed immediately upon hire, even if the employee elected to defer it until the end of the retention period. And a signing bonus that is actually paid is taxed upon payment, even if it has to be returned if the employee doesn't stay until the end of the retention period, so presumably the same rule would apply to a bonus that is made available.
In the 409A context, presumably in order to avoid this issue, a deferral is recognized only if it is made within the first 30 days, and only if it relates to compensation earned after the election. But a signing bonus is earned upon signing, so that wouldn't work here.
Any thoughts?
Senior Compliance Analyst
Distribution Reviewer
ESOP Consultant
Controlled Group Relationship - Household Employees
Hi,
I have a question about a Controlled Group relationship.
A sponsor owns two companies: A and B. For company A, she has a 401(k) Plan and there is no 401(k) Plan for company B. Company B is currently an LLC (that she also owns 100% of) where she has 1 household employee. She is thinking of dissolving the LLC to avoid the 2 companies being in a Controlled Group relationship.
According to the plan sponsor, the household employee (at Company B) is not part of a trade or business (and their payroll and any 401k contributions would not be tax deductible) so they believe the household employee would not need to be covered by the Company A's 401(k) Plan if the LLC is dissolved.
"Reading from IRC 414:
(c)Employees of partnerships, proprietorships, etc., which are under common control
(1)In general
Except as provided in paragraph (2), for purposes of sections 401, 408(k), 408(p), 410, 411, 415, and 416, under regulations prescribed by the Secretary, all employees of trades or businesses (whether or not incorporated) which are under common control shall be treated as employed by a single employer."
Is this still a Controlled Group relationship and would the household employee from Company B need to be covered by Company A's 401(k) Plan.
Receivable Contributions & RMD
I tried to find this, but couldn't seem to. If an owner is RMD eligible, actively working and receiving a Profit Sharing contribution for his 12/31 balance do you use:
1) The Investment Balance
2) The Investment Balance + any Receivable contributions made after the close of the year
I just wanted to be 100% sure, as I'm started to confuse myself.
Thanks everyone!







