- 0 replies
- 820 views
- Add Reply
- 2 replies
- 3,017 views
- Add Reply
- 3 replies
- 2,224 views
- Add Reply
- 2 replies
- 1,233 views
- Add Reply
- 1 reply
- 910 views
- Add Reply
- 2 replies
- 1,457 views
- Add Reply
- 3 replies
- 1,462 views
- Add Reply
- 19 replies
- 8,377 views
- Add Reply
- 4 replies
- 1,378 views
- Add Reply
- 12 replies
- 2,144 views
- Add Reply
- 2 replies
- 5,012 views
- Add Reply
- 2 replies
- 1,204 views
- Add Reply
- 5 replies
- 1,837 views
- Add Reply
- 3 replies
- 1,729 views
- Add Reply
Adding QACA to an existing safe harbor match plan
An employer wants to amend their plan to adopt QACA. Can they have QACA apply to just employees hired after a certain date or does QACA have to apply to everyone? They currently have a basic safe harbor match plan. The QACA match differs from the SHM and having 2 different SHM formulas in the plan is not permitted (I think).
The employer would prefer not to have existing employees have to go through any enrollment process or have anyone currently employed defaulted into the plan. But if everyone currently employed has an affirmative election to participate or not in the plan, would those employees really need to complete anything for the QACA? I would think not.
Thank you for replies
Staff Accountant 2
COBRA Subsidy
Hello,
My employer has done quite a few layoffs this year and has offered those former employees COBRA subsidies as part of their severance agreement. My question is: if an employee is offered a COBRA Subsidy for a certain number of months, but does not actually elect COBRA, does that amount still need to be reported on their w2 for informational purposes? Or does it only need to be included if they elect COBRA?
SECURE 2.0 - Amend now or later?
We just received the 2025 SECURE 2.0 Amendment from ftWilliam. Most, if not all, of our clients will be going with the default selections in the amendment.
Out of curiosity, are firms having their clients formally adopt the amendment now, or are most waiting until the required deadline of December 31, 2026?
Thank you!
SECURE Act Amendments for 401(k)
A few questions questions regarding SECURE Act amendments:
1. My understanding is that 401(k) plan documents have until December 31, 2026 to be amended for any secured act provisions, even if operationally implemented earlier (e,g, Roth catch-up elections implemented in 2025). Is this correct?
2. Are plan amendments required for:
a. The annual paper statement requirement of Secure 2.0 Sec 338 - my inclination is that you wouldn't have to unless there were something in the plan document that suggested something to the contrary.
b. The disclosures for eligible unenrolled participants requirements of Secure 2.0 Sec. 320 - again, my inclination is that you wouldn't have to unless there were something in the plan document that suggested something to the contrary.
Thanks!
record keeping and online access
We have a small group of DB plans and work with an excellent actuary. Our plans are generally small but for one with several hundred participants. The sponsor wishes to start a new DB plan but would like it to look like their 401(k) - online access to see balance, process distributions online, etc.
Does anyone know if Ascensus has such a product. I did a search on them and was directed to their subsidiary Future Plan. Thank you for any comments.
3(16) Retirement Plan & Customer Liaison
Form 5500 on EFAST prior to 2009
We are helping a takeover client with a DFVCP filing. The EFAST site only goes back to 2009 filings which makes sense. When going to the DFVCP payment web site, it lists Forms 5500 going back to 2004 as "late filings found in EFAST at this time."
Question is how are pre 2009 Forms showing up on the DFVCP site as being on the EFAST site, but they are not actually displayed on the EFAST site. Maybe the client filed electronically, but it is not displayed on the EFAST site? In any case how do we amend those pre-2009 Forms and submit under DFVCP?
Hope someone has experience with this. Thank you!
Participant Services & Operations Coordinator
Enrolled Actuary
Failed 414s test in safe harbor plan
Safe harbor plan fails compensation ratio test for the match since bonuses are excluded. The plan document does not provide any type of correction method such as use total compensation. Does an 11(g) amendment correct this situation where compensation would be added back? I remember hearing in the past that if a safe harbor plan fails compensation tests it blows the safe harbor, unless the base document has a correction like the AQSC document does. This plan uses a pre-approved document but no correction language has been located. How do we proceed? Thanks!
401(k) Plan Mega Roth Backdoor After Tax Contributions
Hi, I've worked on 401k plans for a while now, but encountered mega roth backdoor quite recently. I do understand that it has great tax saving for an individual but after digging deeper I read that ACP must be passed for the after tax voluntary contributions even if the plan is safe harbor and passed ADP and ACP for matching. Am I understanding this correctly? Also is there any way to bypass the testing for mega roth backdoor after tax contributions?
Thanks!
Defined Benefit and/or Cash Balance Pension Administrator
Retirement Plan Administrator (Part-Time)
Cross Testing and Terminated Participants
So, every day I find something that I thought I knew and now question my entire life.
Most of our safe harbor plans we write with no hours or last day requirement for the new comparability profit sharing to allow for flexibility (they have to get the gateway anyway for SHNEC). I am now questioning a safe harbor match plan with new comparability PS. We sometimes don't give the PS to HCEs (spouses, non-owners) and terminated employees. As long as it passes, we figure it's ok. I went down a rabbit hole today with chatgpt and he/she/it told me that if the SPD is explicit in saying they will receive a PS, then they have to receive it.
This is what the SPD says: Discretionary Employer Contribution formula. We will decide each year how much, if any, we will contribute to the Plan. Since this Employer Contribution is discretionary, we may decide not to make an Employer Contribution for a given year. We may decide to give a different contribution to each eligible participant under the Plan. The Employer Contribution may be determined as a percentage of compensation or as a dollar amount. We will inform you of the amount of your Employer Contribution once we determine how much we will be contributing for the year.
Employer Contributions. Under the Plan, as amended, you do not have to satisfy any additional allocation conditions under the Plan. Thus, you will be entitled to share in any Employer Contributions we make to the Plan if you satisfy the eligibility conditions applicable to Employer Contributions regardless of how many hours you work during the year or whether you terminate employment during the year.
If this is a SHM plan - do we have to give a PS to terminated participants OR HCEs as long as we pass the required testing (401(a)(4), 410(b), TH)? I
Thanks!
Can Plan just disappear?
New solo 401(k) Plan was signed/adopted 5 years ago.
No contributions have ever been made.
Only filing ever done was to create a Trust EIN.
'Plan Sponsor' would like to "disappear" the plan and start a SEP this year.
I'm just processing what steps to take.
Late deferrals: calculating lost earnings
Often, when there are late deferrals to a plan, TPAs are using the DOL VFCP calculator to determine lost earnings. I understand that's only allowable if the Sponsor is filing under VFCP. And if not submitting, they must use EPCRS to determine the earnings.
The first and best option is to calculate actual earnings for everyone involved. Than can get hectic if there are more than a few participants involved, or multiple payrolls. Hectic and pricey--we charge by the hour, and the cost can easily overtake any benefit to the participants.
We may have a way to calculate the Rate of Return (RoR) individually for each payroll, rather than exact earnings.
My question is this: Is that enough? Using the RoR per participant (and if unavailable, the RoR for the during the same timeframe?)
The DOL calculator determines not only lost interest, but the interest on the interest. Would I need to do TWO calculations? First determine lost interest from payroll date to deposit and then another from deposit until 'today'?
How do you guys do it? Several colleagues at other firms just take the path of least resistance and still use the DoL calculator.
I haven't heard anyone getting in trouble for doing it that way. Have you?
2 Single Member Business', same owner... can either business pay the ER Cont?
This client owns a business and is going to open another business (both in the financial arena). I can use the same plan document for both plans... using the joinder agreement option... it's a control group.
IF the client wants to max out the ER, does it matter which business ponies up the money? OR... if the client earns $100K from company A then company A needs to pony up $25K (and so on with Company B)
Thanks
New Employer - Short Tax Year
A new company's inception is 9/1/2025. There is one employee, the S-Corp owner. First tax year runs 9/1/2025 to 12/31/2025. Owner wants to adopt a calendar year profit sharing only plan for 2025, adding 401(k) for 1/1/2026. W2 comp for the period 9/1/2025 to 12/31/2025 will exceed $350,000. In the EOB it seems to indicate that it is possible for the effective date of the plan to begin prior to the inception date of the company. The EOB indicates that the IRS informally expressed this view at benefit conferences. It also notes that the employer can highlight the issue in the plan's determination letter request which seems to indicate that this wording has been in the EOB for a long time.
Is this an acceptable approach?
If not, and the plan year must be a short plan year (9/1/2025 to 12/31/2025) to run as a calendar year plan, are we then prorating the compensation limit to $116,667 (4/12ths) and in turn using that pro-rated limit to determine the max deductible amount of $29,167 (25% of prorated limit).
Thank you very much.
Can plan make vesting more liberal only for Active participants?
I thought this seemed pretty simple but now I am getting confused ..
401k plan currently has 6-year vesting schedule.
They would like to amend the schedule to a 5-year schedule, which will be more advantageous at every year. They are doing this because they feel like their current schedule is not competitive in their industry.
However, they do not want to give the new vesting schedule to anyone who is terminated but still has money in the plan.
Can the amendment state that only participants who work an hour of service on or after the effective date of the amendment will be subject to the better vesting schedule? And they want the new schedule to apply to all of the money in the accounts of anyone who is still employed on the date of the amendment (ie., they don't want to only apply the vesting schedule to new contributions made after that date).
I guess where I am getting confused is, Is there a requirement that anyone with at least 3 years service (including terminated participants) must be allowed to elect the better schedule?
Thanks!!







