- 2 replies
- 4,652 views
- Add Reply
- 3 replies
- 1,770 views
- Add Reply
- 12 replies
- 2,696 views
- Add Reply
- 20 replies
- 3,241 views
- Add Reply
- 2 replies
- 1,197 views
- Add Reply
- 5 replies
- 2,759 views
- Add Reply
- 2 replies
- 3,900 views
- Add Reply
- 5 replies
- 2,045 views
- Add Reply
- 3 replies
- 2,094 views
- Add Reply
- 2 replies
- 1,370 views
- Add Reply
- 4 replies
- 1,224 views
- Add Reply
- 2 replies
- 1,549 views
- Add Reply
- 5 replies
- 1,385 views
- Add Reply
- 4 replies
- 1,817 views
- Add Reply
- 3 replies
- 1,347 views
- Add Reply
- 3 replies
- 1,947 views
- Add Reply
- 4 replies
- 1,309 views
- Add Reply
- 1 reply
- 1,112 views
- Add Reply
- 2 replies
- 4,517 views
- Add Reply
- 4 replies
- 2,157 views
- Add Reply
COBRA Election Notice Timeline
Hello. We have some layoffs happening at the end of the month, which employees have already been made aware of. If benefits also end on the last day of the month, are we able to provide the COBRA notices early (now for example) and will they be able to elect COBRA prior to their termination date on 6/30? Or is there a law that states they cannot elect COBRA until the qualifying event occurs (6/30 term date)?
410 b test failure options for average benefits?
Have a safe harbor 401(k) Plan. Deferral and match only. The plan fails 410b. If we run 401a4 test by allocation rate, it fails. Can we run it using benefit accrual rates to get it to pass? and not have to meet any minimum gateway requirements?
Unqualified Asset - Private Equity/Stock in 401k Plan
I know that the #1 best answer to my question will be "hire an ERISA attorney". But I'm hoping someone here has experience, and can relay their thoughts on my PITA situation. And please don't fuss at me too much; only looking for real life experience, not scolding. I hate non-qualified assets in a Plan, but this wasn't my idea.
Background info:
-- Medical practice with 401k, Trustee is the doctor. 73% of the Plan assets belong to the owner (Dr), his wife, and his daughter, and the other 27% belongs to 9 NHCE participants.
-- 56% of assets are in a pooled account (Schwab) + 44% is in private stock (this valuation is part of my question though, so the 44% may not be accurate). All requirements are being met concerning the 5500/Sch I/audit reqm't.
-- This 401k Plan purchased the private stock for $2/share in 2019. The company prepared IRS Forms 5498(?) in 2022 stating its value as $17.57/share. There is going to be a valuation done this fall (b/c of a capital-raise) and most likely a sale of the company next year. (Thank goodness) So in this plan, the stock asset showed a large gain in 2022, to reflect the value of $17.57/share.
-- The doctor is now very worried the value will drop to $0, and wants to report its value on 12/31/25 as being back at the purchase price of $2/sh.
-- One of the 9 NHCE participants was paid out during 2024, and her vested balance was determined using the Schwab account + private stock at $17.57/share. She was paid out of the Schwab acct to avoid having to transfer shares of the private stock in-kind (would be very impractical).
Question --
(1) Can we make future plan distributions by paying out their share of the Schwab account, but hold back their portion of the private stock to be paid once it liquidates? They'd get the 2nd payout as soon as that occurs.
(2) Should we reflect the asset's value back down at the $2/share? Or is the more accurate value the $17.57/share as reported by the company to its other share-holders?
There is no way to really know how much it's worth until it does actually sell. I personally believe the $17.57/sh valuation is the more accurate of the two since that is what has been used consistently in this plan since 2022, and in other reportings outside of just this plan since then as well.
My main objective, of course, is to be as fair as possible to the NHCE participants in the plan.
THANK YOU.
Amending valuation during audit
Hi,
Thank you, as always for all the insights.
A DB plan (traditional DB) with owner and wife in plan (both owners) and employees. In early 2022, the plan's benefit formula was amended from 2% of average Compensation per year of service to 3% per year of service. The owner had been battling an illness, and passed away towards the end of 2022. When the 2022 valuation was done (year end 12/31/22 val date), inadvertently the original 2% of comp per yr of service, was still used. This was noticed after the fact, after the 2022 5500 had been filed already.
The 2023 val was preformed with using the amended formula of 3% of avearge compensation. Being that as of 12/31/ 2022 the acrued benefit for the owner was suposed to have been based on 3% of comp, the AB for the owner in the 2023 valuation was input based on the 3% as of 12/31/2022.
The valuation and filing for 2022 was not amended to properly match the 2022 plan amendnent of 3% of average compensation per yr of service. And therefore, the AB for the owner shown in the 2023 val does not match the AB shown for him in the 2022 val, (although of course they should match, since there were no further accruals for the owner after the 2022 plan year)
If the 2022 year is under examination, can the 2022 valuation and 5500 be amended now to properly reflect the plans specs of 3%? (as a val should properly match the plan document specs).
Yes, there is a general concept that you can't file an amended 5500 that changes the specs (ie originally filed based on 2% of comp and now amending based on 3% of comp). However, in this case, since the 2023 valuation shows the owners AB based on using 3% for 2022, this clearly indicates that the 2022 was supposed to have been originally filed based on the amendment of 3%?
Thank you for any insights and input.
Designated Beneficiary (Annulment)
Anyone dealt with the issue of how an annulled marriage impacts a beneficiary designation? Participant designates sister as beneficiary and then gets married. The spouse becomes the beneficiary under the plans terms (no spousal consent for sister to remain beneficiary). The marriage is later annulled? Is the marriage treated as if it didn't happen, which in effect reinstates the sister as beneficiary?
Beneficiary designation with multiple beneficiaries
Interesting question. We don't really handle DB plans any longer, but have a couple of "legacy" plans that we handle, working with an outside actuary, of course. Participant in one plan is VERY old, but still working. Unmarried. Has now designated his children as primary beneficiaries, in equal shares.
The plan is silent on whether multiple beneficiaries are allowed. The actuary has opined that administratively, it isn't a problem to appropriately calculate and split the death benefit amongst the beneficiaries.
If the Employer (Plan Administrator) writes up a basic policy stating that multiple beneficiaries are allowed, do you see a problem with it? Seems to me that in the absence of a clear document provision/directive one way or the other, that it should be ok?
P.S. I should have mentioned - these are governmental plans, if that makes any difference in your opinions.
Reasonable Compensation Guidance
Please share any DOL guidance or opinion letters you may have come across that address the issue of determining whether compensation paid to an investment manager hired for the sole purpose of managing a plan's assets is reasonable compensation under 2550-408c-2(b)(1) - (b)(4). Investment manager is a fiduciary.
Funds accumulated for at least two years: meaning?
Plan allows for 59 1/2 withdrawal but only:
• the portion of your account being withdrawn has accumulated in the Plan for at least two (2) years
What does that mean? Up to the account balance two years ago? Or everything now minus any contributions in the past 24 months?
For example, my account is worth $10,000 now but I added $1,500 in contribs in the past 2 years. Two years ago, the account was worth $7,900. how much can I take? $8,500 or $7,900?
414(s) Test
I'm a plan auditor and have a 401k Plan that excludes bonuses from its definition of compensation, so it gets tested under 414s. The Plan does fail the ADP test and the needed corrections were made. The 414s test also appear to fail, but its interesting because the HCE % is 90% and the NHCE ratio is 95%, so it's actually a -5% difference, meaning the test shows that more compensation is being excluded for the HCE group than the NHCE group. Given the rules apply to protect the NHCE group, would you consider this a non-issue for compliance purposes? The TPA is being rather vague on the matter.
Does EPCRS require calculating and depositing "earnings on earnings" for missed contributions?
For example, if a missed nonelective contribution for a participant should have been deposited on day 1, and the corrective contribution was deposited on day 100, earnings would of course be calculated from day 1 through day 100.
What if the earnings contribution is not deposited until day 150? Must the earnings calculation be adjusted to also account for the additional 50 days it took to deposit the earnings contribution - or is the calculation only of earning from day 1 through 100 sufficient?
Participant not notified of eligibility - Correction
If the Plan Sponsor did not inform an employee of their eligibility (and did not provide any 401(k) documents to the participant), what would be the correction procedure?
The plan is a 4% Safe Harbor Match plan. Only HCEs deferred, so we don't know the NHCE ADP.
Thanks!
Roth Catch Up 1.1.2026
clearly if the participant earned in excess of the dollar threshold, any catch up contributions would be funded as Roth Contributions.
What happens if the plan fails the ADP test and funds are "reclassified" Roth contributions? I would image the requirement to fund catch up with Roth would not apply in this case since the contributions were part of the 402(g) limit, funded with pre tax and not a REAL catch up.
Am I correct?
Using a client for personal work
So I'm in need of an electrician and my business happens to have an electrician as a client.
What is a best practice protocol? I'm not interested in getting any kind of discount so I hesitate to inform the owner that I'm reaching out to their business for fear they might offer a special rate. But I worry that best practice is I should let them know first.
Authorization to file 5500 on behalf
Just curious - for those 5500's we file, we always request a written signature on an annual basis to file 5500's on behalf of Plan Sponsors (we only do this for the super small plans).
Generally, they email a pdf with the signature.
Has anyone transitioned to getting this authorization by email only? ie. have the plan sponsor respond yes by email without a wet signature?
Subject to 409A or No?
A bit of a brain teaser here. A proposed arrangement would provide installment payments to an employee (or beneficiary) over a period up to 3 years only upon the employee's disability or death that occurs while employed and prior to a change in control of the employer. The 409A regs provide that 409A does not apply to a plan to the extent that it provides disability pay or death benefits. For this purpose, "disability pay" and "death benefits" are defined under the FICA regs.
The FICA regs (31.3121(v)(2)-1(b)(3)(iv)) provide that payments under a plan in the event of disability are disability pay to the extent that the disability benefits payable under the plan exceed the lifetime benefits payable under the plan. The regs define "lifetime benefits" as the present value of the benefits that could be payable to the employee under the plan during the employee's lifetime. Because the only other benefits payable under the plan would be after the employee's death, it appears that the payments upon disability are "disability pay" not subject to 409A.
Similarly, the FICA regs provide that payments under a plan in the event of death are death benefits to the extent that the total benefits payable under the plan exceed the lifetime benefits payable under the plan. Using the same definition of "lifetime benefits" as above, it appears that the disability payments (which could be payable during the employee's lifetime) would prevent the death payments from qualifying as "death benefits," thus subjecting the arrangement to 409A. But this seems like an odd result, considering the similarity of the provisions for disability pay and death benefits, so is there an argument that benefits that constitute "disability pay" are disregarded in determining "lifetime benefits" so that the death payments constitute "death benefits" and the entire arrangement is not covered by 409A?
Insurance Question
We don't administer very many plans that have insurance but this particular plan is a one participant traditional defined benefit plan that we inherited. When the plan was established, the proper amount of insurance was purchased (no more than 100x the projected benefit).
Is this 100x rule effective just for the year the insurance was put in place? I would think so for the following reasons:
1. The company could have an unexpected downturn in business resulting in smaller average compensation and therefore a smaller benefit than anticipated.
2. The plan could be frozen at some point for a few years or so and then the participant might end up with a smaller benefit than what the original projected benefit was.
Thanks.
Testing & 5500 for plan with brokerage and vendor accounts
Noob 2024 testing & 5500 SF questions here:
1. For a 401k plan (accrual basis, Basic match SH w/ Proft Sharing contributions ) with both vendor and brokerage accounts - if a brokerage account includes only one participant out of 30 employees on census and deposits to that account total $68000 for example - is the entire $68,000 included in with the total of the vendor/recordkeeper total contributions on 5500-SF or just the max allowable annual limits by source? In this example 30,500 Roth and max SH match. The plan hasn’t decided on PS contribution amount for 2024
2. How do you determine the contribution source if the brokerage account statements list only ‘deposit’?
This is my first plan with both vendor and brokerage accounts, and I’m unsure how the two are handled together on the 5500, and how the brokerage account deposits are broken down by source
Thanks!
Is a Non-owner spouse considered an HCE for 2024 if newly married?
Is a non-owner spouse considered an HCE for 2024 if they were married to the owner at the beginning of December in 2024? Would the wife be looked at as HCE for all of 2024 in testing?
Corporate acquisition/plan termination/415
I'm trying to figure out the rules when a plan is terminated just before the employer is acquired, and its employees are thereafter covered by the acquirer's plan.
Let's call the acquired company A and its plan, Plan A. The acquiring company's plan is Plan B. The IRS site says that the 415 limit is prorated for a terminating plan, but not in the case of an individual who joins a plan late in the year. And of course, plans of a single employer are combined.
In this case, presumably Plan A must apply a prorated 415 limit to contributions made before its termination. But because the employees of A have been employed by the same entity all year, and Plan B did not have a short plan year, presumably Plan B must combine its benefits with those of Plan A in calculating the 415 limits for Plan B.
But does the reverse apply? Must Plan A combine its benefits with those of Plan B in calculating the 415 limits for Plan A? Common sense would seem to say no. Plan A had a short plan year, and no contributions were made to Plan B on behalf of A employees during that short plan year. But I haven't found authority directly on point.
Discretionary Match
Is it possible for a plan with a safe harbor match to also offer a discretionary match and still retain its safe harbor status, i.e., avoid adp/acp testing & TH mins? In other words, a triple stack match without a fixed match - could that still be considered a safe harbor plan? If so, what would be the limitations on the discretionary match?







