Jump to content

    class based allocation chicanery

    AlbanyConsultant
    By AlbanyConsultant,

    I've got a client who asked if they could use the xt allocation in the plan to not allocate "profit sharing" (I know, I know) to anyone who doesn't already have an account in the plan.  They have several thousand employees and a lot of turnover (but they are required by donors to have a very generous eligibility provision), so trying to get accounts set up for small employer allocations that are then immediately withdrawn is a hassle - they'd rather direct the contribution to more stable employees.

    Acknowledging that there is still a lot of work to do to firmly establish the parameters here... how off-kilter is this idea?  The AA does allow for classes of individual participants.  And they don't necessarily want a match.  They are OK with the allocation going to participants who terminated during the year who have previously opened an account (i.e., deferred).

    Let's say that I can pass 410b somehow - maybe by not giving the HCEs any allocation (which would be best for gateway and the rest of 401a4 testing).  Is there anything else that would prevent this kind of skullduggery?

    Thanks.


    RMD - non-calendar year DC plan

    shERPA
    By shERPA,

    I’ve been retired a few years, so maybe I’m missing something?  A former client contacted me with questions re his 2026 RMD.  Non-calendar yr PS plan with an annual val date of 6/30.  So use the 6/30/25 account value less any distributions plus any contributions made between 7/1/25 and 12/31/25 to determine the 26 RMD.   He took his 2025 RMD late in 25, as well as an additional distribution rolled to an IRA.  So these distributions get subtracted from the account balance.   

    His (huge, national) TPA firm calculated the RMD without this adjustment, despite the adjustment being defined in both the regs and in the RMD language of said (huge national) TPA firm’s prototype DC plan document. When my client pointed this out to them, the response was “we as a practice calculate the RMD without the adjustments for distributions and contributions after the valuation date.  If you want to use your calculation with the adjustments it is not incorrect to do so.”

    So, “as a practice”, they don’t follow the regs or the plan document?  At least if there are only distributions to subtract worst case the RMD is overstated.  But if they also ignore any contributions, they’d be understating the RMD, leaving the participant subject to a potential excise tax and the employer with an operational violation of the terms of the plan.  

    Am I missing anything here?  Thanks. 

    Jim


    Paychex Policy Requiring January 1 Plan Effective Date for New Plans

    Micks
    By Micks,

     

    I am looking for input from others who work with Paychex recordkeeping.

    We recently received the following explanation from Paychex:

    "Under Paychex recordkeeping, the Effective Date of the plan will always be January 1 of the inception year. On the line below it, you will see the effective date for deferrals as 11/9/2024."

    In the adoption agreement, the Plan Effective Date is listed as 1/1/2024, while the Pre-Tax and Roth Effective Deferral Date is listed as 11/9/2024 and the 2024 filed 5500 shows 11/1/2024.

    My questions are:

    1. Is it Paychex's standard practice to establish all new plans with a January 1 effective date for the inception year, regardless of when the plan is actually adopted?
    2. If the employer adopts the plan later in the year (e.g., November 2024), is there any concern with having the document show a 1/1/2024 Plan Effective Date while deferrals begin on 11/9/2024?
    3. Have any auditors, TPAs, or practitioners encountered operational, compliance, or disclosure issues arising from this approach?
    4. Is there IRS guidance or industry practice supporting this distinction between the plan effective date and the deferral effective date?

    I would appreciate hearing how others have handled this with Paychex or other bundled providers.

    Thanks!


    Actuary

    BenefitsLink
    By BenefitsLink,
    for EGPS (a Blue Ridge Company) (Remote / Baxter MN)

    View the full text of this job opportunity


    Retirement Plan Analyst, Defined Contributions

    BenefitsLink
    By BenefitsLink,
    for Trinity Pension Consultants (Remote / Akron OH)

    View the full text of this job opportunity


    Relationship Manager, Defined Contributions

    BenefitsLink
    By BenefitsLink,
    for Trinity Pension Consultants (Remote / Akron OH)

    View the full text of this job opportunity


    Retirement Plan Administrator

    BenefitsLink
    By BenefitsLink,
    for The Pension Design Group (Remote / Columbus OH / Hybrid)

    View the full text of this job opportunity


    Retirement Client Consultant

    BenefitsLink
    By BenefitsLink,
    for Leading Retirement Solutions (Remote)

    View the full text of this job opportunity


    Is a temptation to backdate documents a thing of the past?

    Peter Gulia
    By Peter Gulia,

    About half a generation ago, someone might face a pressure to help a plan’s sponsor date a document falsely. https://benefitslink.com/boards/topic/44420-ethical-dilemma/

    Now, many service providers use software and internet delivery to present a ready-to-sign document, and expect a plan sponsor’s adoption or approval through DocuSign or another e-sign tool.

    Is an ink-on-paper signature such a disruption that it’s too hard to pretend a document was signed sooner than when the plan sponsor signed it?

    Are there still situations in which a temptation to date a document falsely persists?


    Vice President, Investment and Wealth Solutions

    BenefitsLink
    By BenefitsLink,

    Health Insurance Specialist

    BenefitsLink
    By BenefitsLink,
    for Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services [CMS] (CO / GA / MA / MD / MO / TX / WA)

    View the full text of this job opportunity


    Benefits Advisor (Call Monitoring)

    BenefitsLink
    By BenefitsLink,
    for Employee Benefits Security Administration [EBSA] (Washington DC / Hybrid)

    View the full text of this job opportunity


    Amending plan actuarial to 2%

    SSRRS
    By SSRRS,

    Hi,

    Thank you as always. Someone mentioned to me that he was on a conference call with an actuary that works for the PBGC. The actuary suggested, as a remedy for overfunding (since the 417 (e) rates have gone up to the 5% range and lump sums have gone down) to amend the plan's equivalence to the 2% range and this would help raise the liabilties and reduce the overfunding. 

    Is this reasonable to use an interest rate that is quite low,  for the plan equivalence,  and is considerably lower than the current 417(e) rates? Can it be justified?

    This could help solve many overfunded plans, and especially owner only plans (that don't mind raisingvthe liabities fir themselves). Thank you.  


    Senior Retirement Service Consultant

    BenefitsLink
    By BenefitsLink,

    Would you let an AI chatbot do your client acquisition and Form 5500 research?

    Chase Miller
    By Chase Miller,

    I have been experimenting with a new way to use Form 5500 data, and I am curious whether retirement plan professionals would find it useful—or consider it a bridge too far.

    I built a connection between a Form 5500 databaase and AI agents such as Claude Code and Codex. The technical name for the connection is an “MCP,” but the simplest explanation is that it works like a secure data source.

    A normal AI chatbot can talk and write using the open internet, but it cannot automatically reach into a specialized database. The MCP gives it permission to ask PlanProvider.Pro (like Judy Diamond) specific questions and return source-linked answers. You still ask the question in plain English.

    For example:

    • “Look up the retirement plan for these five companies and summarize the latest filing year, participants, and assets.”
    • “Who are the listed advisor, auditor, recordkeeper, and administrator for this plan?”
    • “Find retirement plan auditors in Texas and show me their profiles.”
    • “Turn this named list of prospective employers into a research brief and identify possible reasons for a conversation."

    So the real question may not be, “Would you let AI do your client acqustion research?” It may be, “Which parts of prospect research would you trust it to prepare before a human reviews the work?”

    I would especially like to hear from the skeptics:

    • What research task would you try first?
    • Where would you require a human checkpoint?
    • What mistake or privacy concern would make you refuse to use it?

    Here is the plain-English overview and setup guide:
    https://planprovider.pro/form-5500-ai-mcp

    Full disclosure: I built this, and I am looking for candid feedback—not just compliments.


    IRS Announces 2027 Requirement Contribution Percentage and Adjusted Premium Tax Credit Applicable Percentage Table

    Lois Baker
    By Lois Baker,

    Beginning in calendar year 2026, HHS guidance provided a new premium growth measure that captures increases in individual market premiums in addition to increases in employer-sponsored insurance premiums for purposes of calculating the premium adjustment percentage for the 2026 benefit year and beyond.

    For plan years beginning in calendar year 2027, the Required Contribution Percentage for purposes of § 36B(c)(2)(C)(i)(II) and § 1.36B-2(c)(3)(v)(C) is 10.22%.

    Full text of IRS Rev. Proc. 2026-26 is here.


    DOL Proposes Rule to Modernize Electronic Delivery for Group Health Plans

    Lois Baker
    By Lois Baker,

    The proposed rule would establish a safe harbor allowing approximately 2.8 million group health plans covered by ERISA to provide required documents digitally. Group health plans currently print and mail up to 11 billion sheets of paper each year. The department estimates the proposal could save group health plans $3.9 billion over 10 years while giving participants and beneficiaries easier, more reliable access to their health plan information.

    Any comments?


    Missed Match versus True-Up and related Earnings

    effingeh
    By effingeh,

    Client found that their payroll system was not accurately calculating match for employees participating in Catch-Up. The correction should be to make up the missed match along with any earnings, correct? And there is no waiver or anything (Similar to missed deferrals caught early enough to avoid the need for a QNEC) that exists for match, is there?

    That said, if they do not correct this during the year, these employees should be made whole when the company funds their year-end match true-up. I have never seen these include earnings.

    Is there any reason for this and is there anything the client should consider before choosing one option versus the other? If "correcting" this with the true-up and not funding earnings an issue? Is there a reason that this should be done with earnings because it violates any rule?

    The client is the one who brought this up as they don't see why it should matter how they do it as long as they do and I want to make sure I explain what they're missing, if anything.

    Thanks!


    5500 for first year of a spin off plan

    D Lewis
    By D Lewis,

    We had a plan with 4 sponsors - a controlled group.

    In 2025 2 of the sponsor's participants were spun off to a new plan in anticipation of those 2 sponsor being sold in 2026 and no longer being a controlled group.

    We were told to make sure the new plan for the spin off had the same effective date at the original plan so that it was clear it was a continuation and not a new plan that would be subject to the auto enrollment rules.

    For the first 5500 for 2025, for the plan's effective date, do I use the original plan's effective date from a prior year with a full plan year - or the date of the spin off and show it as a short 1st year?


    Cloud-based CalcAir/Datair

    TinaW
    By TinaW,

    If you have transitioned from the desktop version of CalcAir to the cloud-based platform, have you been satisfied with the conversion?

    We are considering a move to the cloud and would appreciate any feedback on your experience, including:

    1. How easy was the conversion process?
    2. Were you able to successfully migrate your historical data to the new system?
    3. If you manage large plans, how has the cloud version's performance compared to the desktop/on-premises version, particularly during busy season?
    4. Have you experienced any system outages or downtime during busy season?
    5. How responsive and effective has CalcAir support been when issues arose?
    6. Have you noticed any lag in calculations or other performance or security concerns?
    7. Were there any additional challenges or unexpected issues with the cloud-based platform?

    Any insights or lessons learned would be greatly appreciated.

     

Portal by DevFuse · Based on IP.Board Portal by IPS
×
×
  • Create New...